The damned and dispossessed
WHAT MATTERS IN THE ULTIMATE ANALYSIS IS EXPRESSIVE AND EVOCATIVE POWERS OF LANGUAGE, WRITES RAVI VYAS
In his landmark 1893 essay, "The Frontier in American History", Frederick Jackson Turner offered a clear and concrete definition: the frontier was a place occupied by fewer than two people per square mile. But the frontier was obviously not just a geographical location and historians of the American West have often puzzled over the shifting definitions of the word. Finally, the frontier analogy has been taken as a metaphor for promise, progress and ingenuity which was theirs if only they "moved on" to the last frontier where few had gone before. So, when Americans pull up stakes and hit the road, it is usually with a sense of hope and renewal unique to them.
Given this, the plight of the dirt farmers who were forced to evacuate their 40 acres in the Dirt Bowl in Oklahoma of the 1930s was doubly tragic. For the first time in peacetime American history, the country's citizens had to migrate against their will to a location that held nothing for them. And unlike Jews or the gypsies of central Europe, the poor Okies possessed no tradition of painful displacement, no folk culture to explain or absorb the unexpected catastrophe of having to travel to parts unknown. It is in the depiction of this cultural deracination that the immense power of John Steinbeck's The Grapes of Wrath and East of Eden lies — one of the most compelling examinations of dispossession ever written. But while Grapes and Eden have been worked over extensively — especially last year which marked Steinbeck's birth centenary — Of Mice and Men that also deals with dispossession and drift and issues vital to our times — the environment, poverty and homelessness, America's moral decline, racism and ethnicity — has been lost in the shadows.
The story is simple and stark. George and Lennie are itinerant farm workers in 1930s California. George is small and quick; Lennie is huge with superhuman strength but with the brains of a dim-witted child. Just why they stick together is anybody's guess — or rather why George hangs around with Lennie who has nothing in common with him. Lennie sticking with George is no mystery: he worships him, imitates his gestures, and hangs on to his every word. May be it is George's goodness of heart that ties him to Lennie, feeding him, trekking with him from job to job. Or may be it is Lennie's earning power that draws George to him. After all, George dreams of saving up enough to buy a small farm for themselves and settle down in ease and plenty. His account of this idyll, its phrases polished like a treasured fairy-tale is Lennie's greatest treat.
At the start of Steinbeck's story, very much a Laurel and Hardy tragic pair, they arrive at a new farm where their reputation has not caught up with them. The workers are friendly, the boss is decent enough and everything seems to be working out well to begin with. But Curly, the boss's son, is a problem. He is a pugnacious little fellow who doesn't like big people like Lennie. Worse, he has been recently married and his wife more than a little flirt, hanging around the men's quarters and chatting up with them. She is attracted to Lennie. With the key figures in the drama in place, the novel now builds up to a climax. The tension is almost unbearable, and is achieved without comment from Steinbeck. Sentimentality of any kind is out, as if to say that if you want to touch the heart, the text has to become colder. The effect is entirely modern. It is a narrative bare and relentless, the diction simple and the dialogue ordinary farmhand argot.
The debate over how Steinbeck compares with Hemingway and Faulkner, both titans of his generation, who also won the Nobel Prize, is endless. Some critics have sought to dismiss him as less profound and more superficial than the other two, a straightforward storyteller admired by undergraduates rather than a profound intellectual who probed the human psyche. Comparisons are always odious because not everyone is trying to do the same thing. Hemingway's prose is the best in the language but Steinbeck did the same kind of listening and simplifying. Faulkner was certainly more complex and experimental, more in touch with modernism of people like Virginia Woolf and James Joyce, in a way that Steinbeck was not. But that isn't any criteria to measure one against the others. What matters in the ultimate analysis is expressive and evocative powers of language, that is, the power to express whatever it is the writer understands of the world and of life through the telling of stories about people who are made to seem real. Steinbeck does that, as do Hemingway and Faulkner too.
(The Literary Review)
Lastupdate on : Wed, 15 Dec 2010 21:30:00 Makkah time
Lastupdate on : Wed, 15 Dec 2010 18:30:00 GMT
Lastupdate on : Thu, 16 Dec 2010 00:00:00 IST
- MORE FROM OP-ED
ZAHID FAROOQ KILLING
Srinagar, Dec 15: The High Court on Wednesday deferred the Zahid Farooq murder case till tomorrow after it heard half of the arguments of the state government challenging the lower court’s transfer order More
- Srinagar City
FESD contests public complaints; Affected families complain of Govt apathy
GK NEWS NETWORK
Srinagar, Dec 15: For years the residents of the tourist hub of Dalgate have been demanding establishment of a fire station in the area. But the authorities not only failed to meet their demand, they even More
Kathua: A local court on Wednesday sent Kashmir High Court Bar Association president, Mian Abdul Qayoom to ten days judicial remand. Qayoom was re-arrested, from outside Kot Bhalwal Jail, Jammu, immediately More
- News in Brief
Srinagar: Mother of dramatist, Mushtaq Ahmad Khan, passed away at her residence at 434-Jawahar Nagar here on Wednesday, family said. They said her Fateh Khawani would be held on Saturday at 11 AM More
GK NEWS NETWORK
Srinagar, Dec 15: Chief Minister Omar Abdullah has appreciated the efforts of J&K Bank in offering state-of-the-art facilities to the students of rural districts of Rajouri and Poonch. “By bringing More
NISAR AHMED THOKAR
Islamabad, Dec 15: The Pakistan Administered Kashmir Information Minister, Dr. Mehmood Riyaz has said that “there was a great understanding within the international community that a just and equitable More