London, July 21: Pakistan’s former ambassador to US and United Kingdom, Dr Maleeha Lodhi, has said that the youth led unprecedented protests in Kashmir have exposed the spectacular failure of India in the valley.
Referring to the on-going street rage, Dr Lodhi, said terrorism in the South Asian region was the consequence of the Kashmir problem and it was highly critical to deal with the causes and not just the symptoms of the problem.
Dr Lodhi was speaking at an event in the House of Commons organised by Commonwealth Journalists Association (UK) and also addressed by Brian Hanrahan, BBC Diplomatic Correspondent; M J Akbar and Sir Hilary Synnott, Consulting Fellow International Institute for Strategic Studies, author and former diplomat.
“India’s belligerence and its refusal to look beyond its own paradigm had led to the failure of last week’s peace talks or what she described as a protracted diplomatic dance held between Pakistan and India and it also reinforced the pattern of the inability of both neighbours to manage differences,” she said.
Dr Lodhi said the attitude of India towards Pakistan was similar to the one that is adopted by Israel and Palestinians where the mighty power always tries to arm-twist and dictate its own terms for dialogue. “You cannot hold Pakistan hostage to your own demands and seek a favourable outcome,” she said in reference to India’s total focus on the 26/11 terror attacks in Mumbai while throwing on backburner the core issues.
Dr Lodhi spoke of the three possible scenarios for the near term: a prolonged diplomatic deadlock with fruitless talks continuing but with realisation of the actual issues; a scenario of managed tensions where differences continue but are managed through diplomatic means; and the third being the most desirable scenario where both countries adopt a problem-solving approach to find a resolution of their disputes.
The speakers agreed that the latest wave of popular uprising in Kashmir was a result of the continuing sheer mismanagement in the valley and the failed opportunities by the successive governments to introduce true democracy in Kashmir.
They also agreed that both countries knew there was no military solution to the Kashmir problem.
M J Akbar insisted that Kashmiri youth rage didn’t mean that there was a hatred for India. “The Kashmiri youth are eager to join India in security services, they want to be a part of the entertainment industry and it was imperative they were accommodated.”
Sir Hilary Synnott said he saw no chance of any Western power playing a role leading to the resolution of Kashmir dispute. The speakers agreed that it was in the best interests of both countries to engage in a meaningful dialogue to resolve the differences leading to the unlocking of the true potential of both India and Pakistan.

Lastupdate on : Wed, 21 Jul 2010 21:30:00 Mecca time
Lastupdate on : Wed, 21 Jul 2010 18:30:00 GMT
Lastupdate on : Thu, 22 Jul 2010 00:00:00 IST