Compulsory narco, brain-mapping wrong: SC
PRESS TRUST OF INDIA
New Delhi, May 5: In a blow to investigating agencies, the Supreme Court Wednesday declared as “illegal” compulsory use of narco-analysis, brain-mapping and polygraph tests on suspects.
It, however, held that if anything is obtained by the investigators from such techniques in which a person had volunteered, the agencies can use that for further probe.
“We are of the considered opinion that no individual can be forced and subjected to such techniques involuntarily, and by doing so it amounts to unwarranted intrusion of personal liberty,” a bench headed by Chief Justice KG Balakrishnan said.
The apex court said that involuntarily subjecting an accused, a suspect or a witness to such techniques violates Article 20 (3) of the Constitution, which prohibits self- incrimination.
The judgement assumes significance as probe agencies have used narco-analysis, brain-mapping and polygraph tests in a number of high-profile cases involving fake stamp paper kingpin Abdul Karim Telgi, Nithari killings accused and Aarushi murder case suspects as well as parents of the teenager.
The bench, also comprising Justices R V Raveendran and Dalveer Bhandari, observed that forcing an individual to such methods of investigation violates the scheme of legal process.
Even if a person is subjected to such a mode of investigation on consent, the result of the test cannot be an admissible piece of evidence, it said.
The Supreme Court had on January 25, 2008 reserved its order on a batch of petitions challenging investigation techniques like brain mapping, lie detection and narco- analysis as being illegal and unconstitutional, especially in cases where accused were opposed to them.
Those who had moved the apex court included Santokben Sharmanbhai Jadeja, a woman accused of leading an underworld gang in Gujarat, Tamil Film producer K Venkateswara Rao, fake stamp paper scam accused Dilip Kamath and independent Maharashtra MLA Anil Gote.
The Centre had favoured use of technology in the criminal investigation before the Court maintaining that narco-analysis, brain mapping and polygraph tests are integral tools of probe which were legal and valid.
The Delhi High Court had also recently restrained police from going ahead with narco-analysis test on top Maoist leader Kobad Ghandy in view of the pendency of the legality of such tests in the apex court.
The Supreme Court bench said subjecting a person to such techniques amounts to intrusion of personal liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution.
The court further observed that in conducting the polygraph test, the investigating agencies have to follow strictly the guidelines laid down by the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC).
During the hearing on the matter, the Centre had submitted that these tests provided some clues to the investigating agencies and did not have any evidentiary value per se.
Even Law Commission was of the opinion that such a provision was necessary for effective investigation and it would not affect the fundamental rights, it had said, adding “no invasive procedure is involved” in using modes of investigation like lie detector and the brain mapping tests.
It had argued that the use of narco analysis was of particular relevance in the context of terrorist-related cases, conspiracy to commit murder and other serious offences in which probe agencies got vital leads for follow up action.
On May 3, a Rajasthan court had granted the state’s Anti- Terrorism Squad permission to conduct narco-test on Devendra Gupta, an accused in the 2007 Ajmer Dargah blast case.
Lastupdate on : Wed, 5 May 2010 21:30:00 Makkah time
Lastupdate on : Wed, 5 May 2010 18:30:00 GMT
Lastupdate on : Thu, 6 May 2010 00:00:00 IST
- MORE FROM SOUTH ASIA
Poses As BSNL Official; Forges Documents, Signatures
Islamabad, May 5: Hundreds of people in this south Kashmir district have been duped of lakhs of rupees by an impersonator posing to be the junior engineer in the Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (BSNL). The More
- Srinagar City
'Raid wine shops 'to keep liquor prices under control'
Sharab Ko Aam KarooSrinagar, May 5: At a time when consumers complain that edibles, particularly mutton and chickens are being sold at inflated prices, the authorities seem concerned for boozers by keeping More
State starts techno-feasibility report
GK NEWS NETWORK
Jammu, May 5: While Pakistan has decided to move International court against India over exploitation of the northern rivers in violation of the Indus Water Treaty, state government has started the techno More
- South Asia
PRESS TRUST OF INDIA
New Delhi, May 5: Pakistan’s former army chief, Gen Jehangir Karamat on Wednesday said that India and Pakistan had made “considerable progress” on resolving the Kashmir issue between 2004 and 2007 More
- GK Business
Srinagar, May 5: Despite several ups and downs it has been marked with, the trade across LoC through Uri-Muzaffarabad route has crossed Rs 200 crore mark by April 2010 end. “Since the inception of More