Does Development justify Degradation?

The taste of the vegetables and fruit has changed in Ladakh. Question is why?

VIEW FROM LADAKH BY MUHAMMAD IQBAL

A Ladakhi proverb says, “Ame oma nat met, gukh pe chhwa gal met” which means “ As mother’s milk is free of disease, running water is free of germs.” Indeed the gentle yet hardy people of this hauntingly beautiful yet tortuously difficult mountainous terrain have lived for centuries in the lap of nature, both benefiting from and equally nurturing its fragile eco-system.   The land of glaciers, stark, treeless mountains, of temperatures plummeting to way below sub-zero, is charecterised by a symbiotic bond between the environment and human life which has allowed the region to retain its immense natural resources and its immense charm. 
It is this charm, which over the last few decades has attracted new entrants to the Ladakh, to the splendour of its untouched beauty, to its unique culture, its way of life.  This has opened up an entirely new dimension in Ladakh’s society, economy, and environment.  The influx of tourists drawn in from across the world, the presence of the Army in this highly strategic zone which shares a border with Pakistan have been the triggers in this process. The fall-out has been a transformation of a quiet, pristine region, which reflected harmonious co-existence with nature into a bustling township, a global village as it were.
For the quintessential resident of Ladakh, it is like a nightmare unfolding. Construction activity is high to cater to the demand of the tourists. The number of vehicles has increased exponentially partly in response to this influx as well as the presence of the Army in this strategically sensitive zone.  Pollution is the fall-out of all aspects of these heightened activities.  Heavy tourist rush means more plastic bottles, cans, and wrappers.  In the absence of a viable garbage management system to cater to the enormous waste it all piles up. In the winter months people particularly by labourers coming from outside use it to light bonfires to keep warm.  This itself sets in motion, another set of environmental concerns. What would a large number of such fires over long winter months do to this ecologically sensitive zone?  This is a question that should be high on the priority of policy makers and implementation agencies in Ladakh.
Ladakh has always faced water shortage.  The local answer to this has been the construction and use of ‘dry toilets’ to conserve water.   Now however, in response to the tourist need, hotels and guesthouses abound in ‘flush toilets’, which use an enormous amount of water, which the region can ill-afford.  The sanitation system is also not designed to deal with the sewage produced, which sets in motion another process of pollution. There is every possibility of such untreated waste entering the main water bodies.
There is another kind of pollution which you cannot see or feel yet is robbing Ladakh of its infinitely serene and quiet environment.  The decimal levels of noise have gone up.  There was a time, not too long ago when the strains of the Daman (dram) surna (flute) used to be heard across the region, marking any festive or social occasion.  This has all but disappeared, its music frozen.  Instead there is another kind of noise produced by PAS (public addressing system) music systems, headphones, I pod, all accessories of the new culture invading Ladakh.
Old-timers in Ladakhi villages remember that more than 25 years ago, seasons were periodical, predictable.  Today, things have changed.  Pollution levels are high.  Even in this ‘cold desert’ of icy mountains, the heat levels have increased phenomenally.  Glaciers are melting at a high rate that too over short periods because of the intensity of heat. This means a run-off of the glacial water down the mountains, too quickly to allow the farmers a continuous use of water for irrigating their fields.  This leaves them literally high and dry once it flows off and they are faced with the specter of very little water coming down the mountains during the remaining season of the crops. A paradox of plentiful water and then a complete dry spell. 
There is another round of havoc this causes. The snow on the mountains is good for nourishing the grass growing underneath.  It actually fertilises the grass making it excellent fodder for animals to graze on, in the summer months once the snow melts.  But the intense heat leading to the snow melting faster means that the time for this process to take place is too short.  This in turn causes the wild animals, who are losing their habitat, their natural feeding grounds to come closer and closer to human habitation for food. Amongst these is the Himalayan goat, Capra Hircus famed for its soft underbelly fur made into the priceless ‘Pashmina’.  The animal needs intense cold to survive and for its winter coat to grow into the required thickness which it then sheds.
The hastened pace of glaciers melting, the loss of natural fodder to wild animals, are all interlinked adding up to the bigger picture which needs to be addressed.  It is time to read what the signs portend in the larger, long-term sense for the region and for its people.
Most villages in the Leh district (Ladakh has two districts, Leh and Kargil) are dependent on glacial water, not only for their fields but also for domestic use.  With fast-melting glaciers and subsequent loss of water, does this mean that people living in these villages would be forced to migrate in search of a more amenable environment? Not immediately perhaps but 20-30 years later?  Is this then not the time to worry about it and do some course correction?
The scenario is a far cry from what the region was and to some the transformation is painful beyond words.  There is a sense of nostalgia, even loss amongst the older inhabitants of Ladakh, particularly those connected with the land, “ Earlier the soil used to be very soft and thus easy to plough.” They also rue that the taste of the vegetables and fruit has changed.  Someone needs to answer their questions.  In a sense, it is an answer; the region is seeking as a whole.

(Charkha Features)
{The writer is the awardee of the first Sanjoy Ghose Special Ladakh Media Awards 2010-11 for persons with disability}

Lastupdate on : Sat, 2 Apr 2011 21:30:00 Makkah time
Lastupdate on : Sat, 2 Apr 2011 18:30:00 GMT
Lastupdate on : Sun, 3 Apr 2011 00:00:00 IST




  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Digg
  • TwitThis
  • Mixx
  • Technorati
  • Facebook
  • NewsVine
  • Reddit
  • Google
  • LinkedIn
  • YahooMyWeb
  • Print News
  • YahooMyWeb

Enter the Security code exactly as you see it in the image security code is CaSe SeNsItIvE(Cookies must be enabled)
  • MORE FROM OPINION

  • Kashmir

SHRC depicts dismal picture of inmates in Kotbalwal Jail

AGENCIES

Srinagar, Apr 2: Prisoners at the Kot-Balwal jail are provided a “ridiculous” quantity of just 58 grams of meat or cheese once in a week while as there is a lack of para-medical staff at the Prison Hospital More



  • Srinagar City

At IGNOU convocation, VC CU hails open university

GK NEWS NETWORK

Srinagar, Apr 2: IGNOU commemorated it’s 22nd  convocation Saturday, which was held simultaneously at its New Delhi headquarters and across all it’s regional centres. The Kashmir chapter organised More




  • Jammu

PSC made 6085 selections in 3-years: Government

GK NEWS NETWORK

Jammu, Apr 2: Claiming that the functioning of Jammu and Kashmir Public Service Commission (JKPSC) had improved considerably over a last few years, the Minister for Finance and Ladakh Affairs Abdul Rahim More



  • Briefs

Hizb condemns civilian killings

Srinagar, Apr 2: The Hizbul Mujahideen on Saturday condemned the killing of civilians in Kashmir. “Since Hizbul Muajhideen’s constitution is based on Quran and Sunnah, it cannot, therefore, allow More



  • Business

SICOP posts Rs 651 cr business turnover

Slathia stresses for industrial dev in far flung areas

GK NEWS NETWORK

Jammu, Apr 2: Minister for Industries & Commerce, S. S. Slathia assured that the Government will continue to attach top priority to the development of industrial sector within the State and take all More



  • News

Another extension for ISI chief

REZAUL H LASKAR/PTI

Islamabad, Apr 2: Confusion surrounding the extension granted to Pakistan's ISI chief Ahmad Shuja Pasha has been cleared after Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani said the General would remain in the post More



ADD
Designed Developed and Maintaned By Imobisoft Ltd /Algosol Software Solutions