Nomination papers cannot be rejected arbitrarily: SC
PRESS TRUST OF INDIA
New Delhi, July 10: Nomination papers of election candidates cannot be rejected without proper scrutiny and reasoning by returning officers as it may lead to "grave consequences" of ensuring victory of a particular contender, the Supreme Court has held.
"We are of the opinion that when a nomination paper is presented it is a bounden duty of the returning officer to receive the nomination, peruse it, point out the defects, if any, and allow candidates to rectify the defects and when the defects are not removed then alone the question of rejection of nomination would arise," the court said in a judgment.
"Any other view, in our opinion, will lead to grave consequences and the returning officers may start refusing to accept the nomination at the threshold which may ensure victory to a particular candidate at the election," it said.
A bench of justices H S Bedi and C K Prasad dismissed Karnataka MLA Nandiesha Reddy's appeal challenging a petition filed in the state high court by Kavitha Mahesh, a candidate whose nomination was rejected by the returning officer for K R Pura Assembly constituency polls held on May 10, 2008.
His election was challenged by Mahesh, inter alia, on the ground that her nomination was illegally rejected by the returning officer which rendered Reddy's election void.
According to the aggrieved candidate, the returning officer rejected her nomination despite the fact that her nomination paper was endorsed by 10 electors and she was not furnished with the copies of the electoral rolls despite several representation. She submitted that on account of the rejection of her nomination paper, Reddy's election was easily facilitated.
The high court had admitted her petition and dismissed Reddy's plea that it cannot be entertained.
Lastupdate on : Sun, 10 Jul 2011 21:30:00 Makkah time
Lastupdate on : Sun, 10 Jul 2011 18:30:00 GMT
Lastupdate on : Mon, 11 Jul 2011 00:00:00 IST
- MORE FROM NEWS
- 35 killed, 200 injured in train disaster in UP
- Piece of British newspaper history comes to end
- India extends diplomatic recognition to South Sudan
- Egypt PM orders sacking of police officers accused of killing protesters
- Nomination papers cannot be rejected arbitrarily: SC
- Urdu media modernises as corporate houses enter mkt
Indira Nagar Fidayeen Attack
D A RASHID
Srinagar, July 10: After eight years of trial a local court acquitted a Pakistani youth accused of storming a paramilitary CRPF headquarters at Indira Nagar here and directed his deportation to Pakistan More
- Srinagar City
Glowing tributes paid to cardiologist’s mother
Srinagar, July 10: While paying rich tributes to his mother Gauri Kaul who recently passed away, renowned cardiologist Dr U Kaul Sunday said Kashmiri Pandits and Muslims should forge unity and “forget More
Jammu, July 10: Accusing ruling National Conference of making mockery of democracy, former Chief Minister and Peoples Democratic Party patron, Mufti Muhammad Sayeed Sunday said his party and Congress had More
Pulwama, July 10: Grandmother of a slain militant of Jaish-e-Muhammad Javaid Ahmad Nengroo died of heart attack during his funeral ceremony at Hanjin village here on Saturday evening. Reports said More
Hails PM for ‘providing job opportunities to JK youth’
GK NEWS NETWORK
Pattan, July 10: Minister for Agriculture Ghulam Hassan Mir today asked the youth to take benefit of the skill development programme under a package announced by Central government recently. The minister More
Lucknow, July 10: At least 35 people were killed and more than 200 injured Sunday when 14 coaches of the Kalka-bound Kalka Mail ran off the rails in Uttar Pradesh, leaving many passengers trapped in the More