Economist censored for Kashmir map
Graphics Shows Where Unofficial Border Actually Falls: Editor
New Delhi, May 24: The Economist magazine has accused India of hostile censorship after officials prevented the distribution of the latest edition, because of a map showing the disputed borders of Kashmir.
Customs officers ordered that 28,000 copies of the influential news weekly should have stickers manually placed over a diagram showing how control of Kashmir, is split between India, Pakistan and China.
Both India and Pakistan claim the whole of the Himalayan region and have gone to war twice over its control since 1947. India imposes tight restrictions on all printed maps, insisting they show all of Kashmir as being part of India.
“India is meant to be a democracy that approves of freedom of speech,” John Micklethwait, editor in chief of The Economist, told AFP.
“But they take a much more hostile attitude on this matter than either Pakistan or China,” he said and added: “This is an act of censorship, and many wise and sensible voices in India see it has no point.”
The map is used as an illustration for the front page story of the latest edition of the magazine on “The world’s most dangerous border” between India and Pakistan.
The Economist still hoped to distribute the edition once the stickers had been added. The map is available on The Economist’s website.
Kashmir is divided between the two nuclear armed neighbours along a de facto border known as the Line of Control. It closely matches the frontline of fighting at the end of the first India-Pakistan war over Kashmir in 1947.
“We are just told ‘it is the law of India’,” Micklethwait said.
“The map is impartial, accurate and fair. We show everyone’s claims, and it is also realistic as it shows where the unofficial border actually falls.”
The magazine has clashed in the past with authorities. In December an entire issue of the Economist was pulped on the censors’ orders over a map of the region, and its publishers predicted the May 21 edition was likely to hit trouble.
The offending maps of The Economist and other foreign publications are routinely targeted by the censors’ office, which stamps each page stating that the borders as shown do not reflect India’s claims.
“As a point of principle we are against changing our articles,” said Micklethwait, speaking by telephone from London on Monday.
“So we mentioned the problem in a piece pointing out how touchy India is on this.”
The magazine also printed a warning saying the map was likely to be censored.
“Unlike their government, we think our Indian readers can face political reality,” it said.
Sham Lal, a senior official in the ministry of information and broadcasting, declined to comment on Micklethwait’s remarks.
“We have no knowledge and no comments to make on this matter,” he told AFP.
Wilson John, a Pakistan expert at the Observer Research Foundation think-tank in New Delhi, said that the map was seen as a national security issue by the government.
“This is about sovereignty,” he said.
“I’m not surprised as this behaviour is an accepted norm in India. Mapping in this region has been an issue for many decades and, because the territorial dispute is far from resolved, maps will remain a problem.”
He added that the country was generally proud of having a free press but that Kashmir “always creates sensitivities that have to be kept in mind”.
Micklethwait said India was now an increasingly modern economic powerhouse with a growing number of Economist readers.
“Other publications have had the same problems, but perhaps we have been more in their face,” he said.
“China will not distribute whole issues for other reasons, but there is no country I know in the world that takes the extreme attitude that India does.” (AFP)
Lastupdate on : Tue, 24 May 2011 21:30:00 Makkah time
Lastupdate on : Tue, 24 May 2011 18:30:00 GMT
Lastupdate on : Wed, 25 May 2011 00:00:00 IST
- MORE FROM FRONTPAGE
MIAN ALTAF CHAIRS HIGH LEVEL MEET
GK NEWS NETWORK
Srinagar, May 24: The Forest Minister Mian Altaf on Tuesday said that Government is contemplating to set up a zoo in Srinagar for which suitable land is being identified. An official spokesman More
- Srinagar City
Raids residential houses, confiscates gardening pipes, boosters
SYED IMRAN ALI HAMDANI
Srinagar, May 24: In a bid to prevent misuse of potable water, the Public Health Engineering Department on Tuesday started a drive against the offenders. The PHE officials in a statement said: “The More
Jammu, May 24: Minister for Public Health Engineering (PHE), and Irrigation and Flood Control, Taj Mohi-ud-Din on Tuesday directed the PHE authorities to increase the daily pumping duration for meeting More
Srinagar, May 24: Polling for the eleventh phase of Panchayat elections would be held in ten blocks in Jammu and Kashmir on Wednesday. In Kashmir Valley four blocks going to polls More
‘Or create lapse fund a/c’
FCIK TELLS PLANNING COMMISSION
GK BUSINESS REPORTERSrinagar, May 24: Valley’s apex industrial body, the Federation Chamber of Industries Kashmir today strongly suggested to the Planning Commission to “fix the plan year for J&K from More
REZAUL H LASKAR
Islamabad, May 24: A complaint registered with police by the Pakistan Navy on the assault on a naval airbase said the attack was carried out by 10-12 militants, contradicting Interior Minister Rehman Malik More