The idea of Lokpal
An independent and effective Lokpal is needed
The success of a democracy and the realization of its socio economic goals depend on the extent to which the grievances of the citizens are redressed. The earliest democratic institutions created in the world for the redressal of public grievances were the Scandinavian institution of Ombudsman. The institution of ombudsman in Indian context is referred to as Lokpal or Lokayukta. The modern state has taken up the activities in all the areas of human endeavour, be it developmental (socio economic nation building), non-developmental (policing, law and order etc) or symbolic (celebrating national holidays, maintaining museums etc).
The rising footprint of the government has meant greater interaction with the citizens, and thus greater chances of corruption, favoritism, harassment and abuse of authority. This makes the setting up of an independent institution of ombudsman/Lokpal a clear necessity. It is in this backdrop that the rising demand for a Lokpal by the members of the civil society (Team Anna) must be seen.
Sweden was the first country to establish the institution of ombudsman in 1809.This later spread to other Scandinavian countries like Finland, Denmark and Norway. The Sweden model of Lokpal, where this institution germinated, has very broad powers. It is an institution appointed by the legislature to look into corruption, abuse of discretion, discourtesy, nepotism and inefficiency. Thus the Team Anna cannot be completely criticized for demanding power for the Lokpal beyond the corruption cases. But it should also be kept in mind that India is huge as compared to Scandinavian countries, and thus the number of cases coming to Lokpal can be unmanageable.
The Sweden model of Lokpal can prosecute any erring official including the judges, but it can only recommend punishment to higher authorities and not inflict any punishment by itself. In Indian context it was the first Administrative Reforms Commission headed by Morarji Desai that first recommended setting up of Lokpal and Lokayuktas in 1966. The first ARC proposed to keep judiciary out of the preview of Lokpal and included ministers and secretaries of central and state governments. Since then there has been eight official attempts to create this institution by way of legislation. The first such attempt was by Indira Gandhi government in 1968. While central government is still debating the establishment of such institutions, many state governments have already set up Lokayuktas.
The first state to do so was Maharashtra in 1971. Orissa passed such an act in 1970, but it came into force only in 1983. The model of Lokayukta varies in different states, and so does its power and authority. Some states have given suo moto power of investigation to Lokayukta while others have not. Some states like Uttar Pradesh and Gujrat have judicial qualification prescribed for the institution, while states like Bihar and Maharashtra have no such criteria. Chief Minister is included in the Lokayukta’s jurisdiction in states like Himachal Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh, while it is excluded from states like Bihar and Orissa.
Thus this wide variation calls for some broad, uniform law from the central government within which the states can pass their own acts. Significant changes have taken place in the politico administrative realities of India since its “Tryst with Destiny” started more than sixty years ago. At the turn of 21st century our administration seems to be mired in the charges of corruption, dishonesty, nepotism, elitism and self aggrandizement. An independent and effective Lokpal will act as the bulwark of democratic government against the tyranny of officialdom. It will be the keeper of public conscience which will increase the faith of citizens in rule of law and help in maturing of our democracy.
Lastupdate on : Wed, 16 May 2012 21:30:00 Makkah time
Lastupdate on : Wed, 16 May 2012 18:30:00 GMT
Lastupdate on : Thu, 17 May 2012 00:00:00 IST
- MORE FROM OPINION
GK NEWS NETWORK
Srinagar, May 16: The recitation of Quran and prayer for Martyrs marked the onset of Hafta Shouda to mark the 22nd martyrdom anniversary of Shaheed-i-Millat Moulvi Muhammad Farooq at Mirwaiz Manzil here More
- Srinagar City
Students, others turn nostalgic about Prof Nazir Ahmed Khan
GK CITY CORRESPONDENT
Srinagar, May 15: It was more of yesteryear collegians bidding a tearful farewell to the then SP College Principal, they were fond of in ‘70s, as iconic Prof Nazir Ahmed Khan was laid to rest Wednesday More
GK NEWS NETWORK
Jammu, May 16: The Jammu and Kashmir Government Employees Association today announced a three-day strike in protest against the government's failure to fulfill their demands of increase in retirement age More
Says MP Quoting Textbook
PRESS TRUST OF INDIA
New Delhi, May 16: Pakistan is a part of India and P V Narasimha Rao is the Prime Minister of the country -- this is being taught to school students in some states, according to a Member of Parliament More