Using Technology in Education
Will technologies replace teachers?
PUPINDER S BALI
It is only a matter of time before technologies come in to replace teachers entirely. The song Brick in the Wall by Pink Floyd is perhaps best remembered for the lines that exhort the teacher to “leave us kids alone”. That captures the state of education, in terms of content and delivery, for millions of us who have been through ‘the system’.
In a State like Jammu and Kashmir, which is perennially short of funds for education, often critically so, it is impossible to train teachers adequately and in numbers to service a large number of children who need to be educated. Add to that badly maintained facilities in schools, high absenteeism among teachers, and the stage is set for a new set of solutions, a revolution by some accounts, to solve this age-old problem.
Universities such as Stanford, MIT, Harvard and IITs have been quick to jump on to the bandwagon. Often criticized as elitist and facing calls to make education more inclusive, these universities have put taped lectures of some of their most popular courses online. A computer engineering student in India, for instance, can now listen to a lecture delivered by a leading computer scientist, who is also a member of the faculty at Stanford. A philosophy student or enthusiast can similarly view philosophy courses at Harvard University’s Youtubechannel from the comfort of his/her home.
Competition in the smartphone and tablet industries has also benefited end consumers greatly. Decreasing prices have ensured that the cheapest Android phone is now available for about Rs 5,000 and the cheapest Android-based tablet can now be bought for about Rs 7,500. The NME-ICT (National Mission on Education through Integrated Communication Technologies), seeks to bring low-cost yet fully functional technologies to students at institutions of higher learning with a view to helping them take advantage of the material that is now increasingly available online.
Launched by Vigyan Prasar and IGNOU on the Science Day, Science@Mobile, an SMS service, will give its subscribers information on a wide variety of science topics free of cost. Subscribers can access this service depending on their level of familiarity with science. The service is now available only in English, though efforts are on to localise this service.
LHSee, an application developed by CERN, is an educational application available on Android that acts as a guide on LHC for the general public. Through videos and complex graphics, each and every part of the massive LHC complex has been laid bare for the layman, and explained in a way that makes this information accessible.
The existing model of delivering education is remarkably democratic. One such underlying assumption is that all children are equal. Children of the same age are grouped together in a class without taking into account that even at the same age, not all children are at the same level of mental development. Some children may be inherently good at some skills, be it hand-eye coordination or spatial skill, and extremely poor in others, such as reading and writing skills.
Given the rapidly evolving nature of technologies to deliver content in innovative ways and the wide dissemination of low-cost devices to deliver such content, it is perhaps only a matter of time before technologies come in to replace teachers entirely. While it does seem to make sense, this notion that teachers can somehow be replaced with content developed in a studio is false. Educational content, no matter how attractive, might never be able to replace a teacher entirely. The way a good teacher can interact, inspire and lead you to question your beliefs is not something that a computer can, at least not for the foreseeable future, do.
Though man has made a lot of progress in a number of fields, education, in terms of the content taught and in the way it is delivered, still follows models and methodologies that have seen little change from the time of the ancient gurukul.
Imbalances between the rich and poor have denied the right to good education to many students who found themselves on the wrong side of the divide. The churn brought about by the ‘democratisation’ of technology is good as it erases this divide and delivers education to a greater number of people at a time and place of their convenience. In the absence of concrete data, the effect of technology on learning outcomes remains to be seen. But the destruction of barriers to learning is a very welcome step.
(Pupinder S Bali is a Sr.Regional Manager, Educational Initiatives -ASSET-India)
Lastupdate on : Sun, 11 Nov 2012 21:30:00 Makkah time
Lastupdate on : Sun, 11 Nov 2012 18:30:00 GMT
Lastupdate on : Mon, 12 Nov 2012 00:00:00 IST
- MORE FROM GKEDUCATION&CAREER
4 IAS Officers On Central Deputation To Return In March
Srinagar, Nov 11: What could bring about some relief to the J&K Government, at least four IAS officers who are presently on deputation at the Government of India are set to return to the State in March More
- Srinagar City
Mufti bashes Govt on skewed bridge, says silly project disastrous for The Bund
GK NEWS NETWORK
Srinagar, Nov 11: Laced with facts and figures, the Peoples Democratic Party Sunday came down heavily on the ruling National Conference led government with the PDP patron and former Chief Minister Mufti More
25 year service fetches them Rs 5700 per month
Jammu, Nov 11: It may sound strange, but it is true- a teacher who has trained 25 batches of Polytechnic College is getting a meager emolument of Rs 5700 per month. This is not the story of one consolidated More
- South Asia
PRESS TRUST OF INDIA
Karachi, Nov 11: At least 31 people, including members of the minority community, have been killed in various incidents of target killings in Pakistan's commercial city of Karachi and Balochistan's capital More
Beirut, Nov 11: Syrian warplanes on Sunday launched air strikes on the eastern town of Albu Kamal near the Iraqi border and pounded rebel lines near Damascus and in the northern city of Aleppo, a watchdog More
INDO ASIAN NEWS SERVICE
New Delhi, Nov 11: Applying chemical-laced 'mehndi' (henna) on the hands can cause serious side effects including skin infection, doctors said, cautioning girls and women against using it. Mehndi More
Locals, tourists suffer, govt mute
Pahalgam: Notwithstanding tall claims of the Government of undertaking equitable development in Kashmir, Aru a famous tourist spot here sans basic amenities causing immense hardships to tourists and locals More