HC dismisses Dr Qasim’s petition
‘Life Imprisonment Means Detention For Entire Life’
D A RASHID
Srinagar, Nov 16: Ruling that life imprisonment means imprisonment for entire life, Jammu and Kashmir High Court Friday dismissed the petition of Muslim League Chairman Dr Muhammad Qasim Faktoo seeking his release.
Justice Mansoor Ahmad Mir announced the judgment after hearing arguments of Faktoo’s counsel Mian Abdul Qayoom and senior Additional Advocate General AM Magray representing the State.
The Court held that the judgment was passed ‘in light of the law laid down by the judgments of Apex Court and other courts’ which it cited while dismissing the petition of Dr Faktoo.
Referring to the argument of counsel for petitioner that in terms of Section 57 of RPC, life imprisonment means imprisonment for 20 years, the court held, “The argument is devoid of any force as the object of the said section is how to calculate the fractions of terms of punishment and provides that imprisonment for life shall be reckoned as equivalent to imprisonment for 20 years, when punishment is to be awarded to a co-accused, who is also involved in the same offence either by abetment, conspiracy or attempt, in which the main accused is awarded the sentence of imprisonment for life.” The court has cited SC judgment titled Swamy Shradananda vs State of Karnataka in this regard.
The court said the contention that the provisions contained in the Jail Manual and Prisons Act mandate that imprisonment for life means 20 years has no substance. “The provisions contained in the Jail Manual, Prisons Act and Prisoners Act are just how to regulate and manage the prisoners in the prisons.” The court cited Apex Court Judgment G. V. Godse vs State of Maharashtra in support of its judgment.
The Court said that the grounds that after completion of 20 years of life imprisonment the convict is automatically entitled to be released is not tenable for the reason that if jail authorities take into consideration the conduct of convict and make a recommendation for his remission or release after 20 years or 14 years, the order of the Government is pre-requisite.
“It is the domain of the Government to consider the case along with the recommendation made and pass the order. Writ of mandamus cannot command the Government for passing such order or to release the convict after expiry of 14 years or 20 years without any specific order,” the Court said.
Mian Abdul Qayoom had argued that Dr Faktoo had earned remission for his good behavior in the jail and his cumulative period of detention came out to be 20 years which amounted to life imprisonment.
He had argued that Dr Faktoo completed 20 years in prison on May 31, 2012, which as per the Jail Manual and Prisons Act amounts to life imprisonment.
“Criminal Procedure Code has no application with our case and it can’t overrule special laws such as Prisoners Act and Jail Manual which provide for the release of Faktoo,” he had argued. Senior Additional Advocate General A M Magray had argued his case on two counts: “remission earned does not mean remission granted and 20 years does not mean life imprisonment.”
He had told the Court that in Faktoo’s case no remission was granted saying there is a palpable difference between remission earned and remission granted. “Remission can’t be claimed as matter of right,” he contended.
He had referred to sections of Criminal Procedure Code and Supreme Court judgments in support of his contention against Faktoo’s release.
Dr Qasim was first detained in 1993 under the Public Safety Act. However, after six years of imprisonment, a TADA court acquitted him of all the charges. Police later rearrested him at the Indira Gandhi International Airport in New Delhi in 2002 after attending a conference on Kashmir in London.
In 2003 he was sentenced to life imprisonment on charges of his alleged involvement in murder of human rights activist, H N Wanchoo. Faktoo had denied the charges.
Earlier, a bench of Jammu and Kashmir High Court had directed to release him in 90 days. The government had challenged the decision in division bench and in September 2011, the division bench observed that TADA convict can’t be released prematurely after 14 years. The division bench said the case be considered only after the imprisonment of 20 years.
Lastupdate on : Fri, 16 Nov 2012 21:30:00 Makkah time
Lastupdate on : Fri, 16 Nov 2012 18:30:00 GMT
Lastupdate on : Sat, 17 Nov 2012 00:00:00 IST
- MORE FROM FRONTPAGE
- Now, Centre throws LPG cap surprise
- KYC forms: Deadline extended till November 30
- HC RAPS JAMMU-BASED DENTAL COLLEGE FOR ILLEGAL ADMISSIONS
- ‘NC, PDP are like two peas in a pod’
- Will consult civil society before Pak visit: Mirwaiz
- NC wants ‘reunion of divided JK’
- PDP fields Hussain, Reshi from Kashmir; Gurmeet, Mahajan from Jammu
- 44 candidates in fray
- Police hushing up cases, rues legislator
- HC dismisses Dr Qasim’s petition
- Hizb hails, but disowns liquor shop attack
Special Team Constituted To Nab Culprits: Police
Shopian, Nov 16: The family of a girl allegedly gang-raped here last week, is awaiting justice as most of the accused are still at large. Police has till now arrested only one of the four accused More
- Srinagar City
Experts press alarm button, seek pause
Srinagar, Nov 16: Kashmir’s harsh Himalayan winter can prove deadly for stray dogs undergoing sterilization at state-of-the-art sterilization facility at Shuhama even as experts have sought immediate halt More
Jammu, Nov 16: A Member Parliament of ruling Congress Friday said the alliance with National Conference in Jammu and Kashmir was a compulsion for the party. “We have compulsion to be in alliance with More
Gaza, Nov 16: The front page photo on Thursday’s Washington Post tells, in a single frame, a very personal story from Wednesday’s Israeli airstrikes on the Gaza Strip. Jihad Misharawi, a BBC Arabic journalist More
- Court Watch
APPOINTMENT OF DHS
D A RASHID
Srinagar, Nov 16: The High Court Friday dismissed the petition challenging the appointment of present director health services Kashmir, Dr Saleem-ur-Rehman. Justice Mansoor Ahmad Mir while announcing More
Man-animal conflict consumes 24 lives in 2 years
Kupwara: Wildlife department has failed to check increasing incidents of man-animal conflict in this north Kashmir district. In past two years, 24 people have been killed by leopards and bears and More