Faith-based academics

For the sake of credible scholarship a rational academic discourse must prevail

Greater Kashmir
Publish Date: Nov 22 2014 9:21PM | Updated Date: Nov 22 2014 9:21PM

Serious concerns are being voiced by academics and historians throughout the country for what are being viewed as clear attempts to introduce a particular faith's view of history, science and political evolution in India.

Some people have publicly voiced their disapproval of attempts to teach the superiority of a particular religion's values and mythology at the cost of academic rigour - something that is widely understood to go against the grain of secularism that binds multi-faith modern India together.

Historians like Romila Thapar have termed all these developments disturbing, and expressed concern that this could impact credible and rigorous scholarship. There are also widespread concerns in the country's research fraternity about actions in the areas of academics that point to signs of a broader plan to bring more Hinduism to the classroom through changes to the curriculum.

The fact that two states being ruled by the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) have recruited a controversial Hindu nationalist to advise on writing textbooks makes the situation ever more concerning.

The experience from the previous BJP rule in India offers not so re-assuring insights for that there were attempts to rewrite school books in line with Hindu-nationalist orthodoxy.

Such attempts did not go well with the vast numbers of other religious minorities in the country. The head of the Indian Council of Historical Research Prof. Y Sudershan Rao's recent comments about the "evidence" of ancient India's progress in modern sciences like aviation and stem cell have already upset many fellow historians.

Mr. Rao was recently appointed to the prestigious academic post by the new BJP government. All this exemplifies the larger thought processes - reflected by none other than the country's new prime minister who raised a public furore both within and outside the country when he said that some holy texts show many discoveries of modern science were made by ancient Indians.

Any such attempts would only be destabilizing - especially in states like Jammu & Kashmir. For the sake of secularism and respectful and credible scholarship a rational academic discourse must prevail in the country.

Latest News

  1. Gun snatched from bank guard recovered within hours: Police
  2. Gun snatched from bank guard recovered within hours: Police
  1. No strike call tomorrow: Joint Resistance Leadership
  2. No strike call tomorrow: Joint Resistance Leadership
  1. Avalanche warning issued for Kashmir areas
  2. Avalanche warning issued for Kashmir areas
  1. Crime Branch registers FIR against imposter
  2. Crime Branch registers FIR against imposter
  1. Jammu and Kashmir universities to have Gojri subject at PG, UG level
  2. Jammu and Kashmir universities to have Gojri subject at PG, UG level
  1. Tourism Minister orders attachment of Director SKICC
  2. Tourism Minister orders attachment of Director SKICC
  1. Maintain discipline during protests against Kathua rape-murder: JRL
  2. Maintain discipline during protests against Kathua rape-murder: JRL
  1. BJP's Jammu and Kashmir unit website hacked for brief period, message seeking justice to Kathua minor posted
  2. BJP's Jammu and Kashmir unit website hacked for brief period, message seeking justice to Kathua minor posted
  1. Teacher jobs: SSB announces changes in test venues
  2. Teacher jobs: SSB announces changes in test venues
  1. Muazzin killed near mosque in Bhopal
  2. Muazzin killed near mosque in Bhopal
  1. Karnataka polls about Hindus versus Muslims, Ram Mandir versus Babri Masjid: BJP legislator
  2. Karnataka polls about Hindus versus Muslims, Ram Mandir versus Babri Masjid: BJP legislator
  1. SC order on Loya shows judiciary cannot be misled: Rajnath Singh
  2. SC order on Loya shows judiciary cannot be misled: Rajnath Singh
  1. Kathua case: Why protest and pelt stones when accused are in jail, asks Naeem Akhtar
  2. Kathua case: Why protest and pelt stones when accused are in jail, asks Naeem Akhtar
  1. Pakistan calls India's claims on surgical strike 'baseless'
  2. Pakistan calls India's claims on surgical strike 'baseless'
  1. Boycott those using mosques to divide Muslims: Mirwaiz
  2. Boycott those using mosques to divide Muslims: Mirwaiz
  1. Sebi scans Facebook 'likes'; finds evidence in insider trading case
  2. Sebi scans Facebook 'likes'; finds evidence in insider trading case
  1. Photographer shot dead during celebratory firing at wedding in Madhya Pradesh
  2. Photographer shot dead during celebratory firing at wedding in Madhya Pradesh
  1. South Kashmir: Rifle of bank guard snatched in Shopian
  2. South Kashmir: Rifle of bank guard snatched in Shopian
  1. Tribal girl raped in Odisha, angry locals block road to demand action
  2. Tribal girl raped in Odisha, angry locals block road to demand action
  1. Woman hit by car in Kulgam, dies: Police
  2. Woman hit by car in Kulgam, dies: Police
  1. Jammu and Kashmir people have shown courage in face of many challenges: President
  2. Jammu and Kashmir people have shown courage in face of many challenges: President
  1. Kathua case: Students clash with government forces in Chadoora in central Kashmir
  2. Kathua case: Students clash with government forces in Chadoora in central Kashmir
  1. Kathua case: Clashes erupt after students hold protest at Ajas Bandipora
  2. Kathua case: Clashes erupt after students hold protest at Ajas Bandipora
  1. It's terrible to even talk about it: Bachchan on Kathua
  2. It's terrible to even talk about it: Bachchan on Kathua
  1. Photograph of SPO posted on social media, passed off as militant: Jammu and Kashmir Police
  2. Photograph of SPO posted on social media, passed off as militant: Jammu and Kashmir Police
  1. Jammu HC Bar Association tells SC it did not support lawyers' protest in Kathua case
  2. Jammu HC Bar Association tells SC it did not support lawyers' protest in Kathua case
  1. Supreme Court for fair trial in Kathua rape-murder case
  2. Supreme Court for fair trial in Kathua rape-murder case
  1. Kathua case: Specially-abled protest in Kupwara, demand death to culprits
  2. Kathua case: Specially-abled protest in Kupwara, demand death to culprits
  1. Kathua case: 14 injured after students clash with forces in Kashmir
  2. Kathua case: 14 injured after students clash with forces in Kashmir
  1. Kathua case: 14 injured by pellets, two in eyes during Shopian clashes
  2. Kathua case: 14 injured by pellets, two in eyes during Shopian clashes
  1. SC dismisses pleas seeking probe in special judge B H Loya's death case
  2. SC dismisses pleas seeking probe in special judge B H Loya's death case
  1. Shutdown in Tral on second straight day
  2. Shutdown in Tral on second straight day
  1. Third-parties abusing 'Facebook Login' to steal users' data: Report
  2. Third-parties abusing 'Facebook Login' to steal users' data: Report
  1. 2 killed in Indonesia quake
  2. 2 killed in Indonesia quake
  1. Chinese forces hold live-fire drill on southeast coast
  2. Chinese forces hold live-fire drill on southeast coast
  1. Kathua case: Students clash with forces in Baramulla
  2. Kathua case: Students clash with forces in Baramulla
  1. Delhi set to get hotter
  2. Delhi set to get hotter
  1. EU official, Zuckerberg discuss privacy protection
  2. EU official, Zuckerberg discuss privacy protection
  1. Trump 'will walk out' if North Korea talks not fruitful
  2. Trump 'will walk out' if North Korea talks not fruitful