CIC disallows disclosure of NHPC records on J&K projects

Cites ‘commercial confidence’, ‘third party’ clauses; Applicant questions decision

PTI
New Delhi, Publish Date: Oct 31 2017 11:25PM | Updated Date: Oct 31 2017 11:25PM
CIC disallows disclosure of NHPC records on J&K projectsFile Photo

The central information commission has rejected an RTI plea seeking disclosure of records related to the discussions on the demand for handing over by the government of India seven NHPC projects in Jammu and Kashmir to the state government, citing exemption clauses of “commercial confidence” and “third party.”

The case pertains to an RTI application filed by activist Venkatesh Nayak seeking communication exchanged between the government of India and the state government regarding the buyback of hydro power projects, feasibility of the proposal and file notings.

“The Jammu and Kashmir government had signed a memorandum of understanding with the Centre in 2000. It states that seven hydro electric projects in the state would be transferred to NHPC Limited for a period of 10 years for funding, execution and operation,” Nayak said.

Giving details of the case, he said that both the Centre and the state agreed in the MoU that they would work out a mutually acceptable methodology for handing over these projects back to the state.

Nayak’s application filed with the Union power ministry was transferred to NHPC limited, a mini-ratna public sector undertaking, which refused to disclose the information, saying it is a listed company and “disclosure would lead to unwanted speculations and confusion among shareholders and affect the commercial confidence of the NHPC.”

“...The Commission (Central Information Commission) discerns that the information sought by the appellant is in the nature of commercially sensitive information, the disclosure of which would not serve any public interest and would lead to unwarranted speculations amongst the shareholders of the respondent PSU and shall affect the commercial confidence of the NHPC Limited,” information commissioner Sudhir Bhargava said.

He said that the information sought is, therefore exempted from disclosure under sections of the RTI Act pertaining to “commercial confidence” and “third party.”

Questioning the decision, Nayak said that the clause of third party does not apply as the public authority which receives the information request and makes a decision on it through its Central Public Information Officer (CPIO), is the ‘second party.’

He said it cannot also be a third party in its own case.

“It may be noted here that NHPC generates more than 40 per cent of the hydel power from plants situated in Jammu and Kashmir,” Naik said.

He said that 12 percent of the power generated is supplied to Jammu and Kashmir free of cost and the state government is required to buy at commercial rates, between 19-20 percent of the power so generated by NHPC, to meet local demands.

“...Treating one public authority as both ‘respondent’ and ‘third party’ in relation to one RTI application leads to an absurdity in law. If this becomes a popular trend, any senior officer in a public authority can claim to be a ‘third party’ to every RTI application and frustrate every information request by objecting to disclosure,” Naik said.

According to Section 11 of the RTI Act, if an applicant seeks information from a public authority about a third party, the concerned official must take views of that party before disclosure. However, the final decision rests with the concerned official who may overrule objections raised by the third party.   

Latest News

  1. Omar Abdullah calls heckling video ‘tamasha’, says Berkeley session was 'great, substantial'
  2. Omar Abdullah calls heckling video ‘tamasha’, says Berkeley session was 'great, substantial'
  1. Delhi based designer Leena Singh dedicates her 2018 collection to Kashmiri craftsmen
  2. Delhi based designer Leena Singh dedicates her 2018 collection to Kashmiri craftsmen
  1. Biker, two accomplices arrested for forcibly stopping scooty rider in Bhadarwah
  2. Biker, two accomplices arrested for forcibly stopping scooty rider in Bhadarwah
  1. Mulling changing law to award death to sexual assaulters of kids: Govt
  2. Mulling changing law to award death to sexual assaulters of kids: Govt
  1. Harsh weather damages orchards and property in south Kashmir
  2. Harsh weather damages orchards and property in south Kashmir
  1. India, Pak trade fire along LoC in Nowshera
  2. India, Pak trade fire along LoC in Nowshera
  1. ‘Wake up your conscience’, legislator Rasheed asks Jammu and Kashmir police
  2. ‘Wake up your conscience’, legislator Rasheed asks Jammu and Kashmir police
  1. Mirwaiz demands justice for Kathua minor, reopening of Kashmir rape cases since 1990
  2. Mirwaiz demands justice for Kathua minor, reopening of Kashmir rape cases since 1990
  1. Prashant Bhushan files complaint against BJP leader who claimed torching Rohingya settlements in Delhi
  2. Prashant Bhushan files complaint against BJP leader who claimed torching Rohingya settlements in Delhi
  1. Nine-year-old raped, killed in Uttar Pradesh
  2. Nine-year-old raped, killed in Uttar Pradesh
  1. Seven parties submit notice to impeach Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra
  2. Seven parties submit notice to impeach Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra
  1. Mobile Internet service snapped in Rajouri after protests over boy's death
  2. Mobile Internet service snapped in Rajouri after protests over boy's death
  1. Kulgam boy putting up at Barzulla found dead, police begins probe
  2. Kulgam boy putting up at Barzulla found dead, police begins probe
  1. Army commanders discuss Kashmir situation
  2. Army commanders discuss Kashmir situation
  1. Former Delhi HC Chief Justice Rajinder Sachar passes away
  2. Former Delhi HC Chief Justice Rajinder Sachar passes away
  1. Internet services suspended in Srinagar
  2. Internet services suspended in Srinagar
  1. Renowned Kashmir cardiologist Dr Sajad Reshi passes away
  2. Renowned Kashmir cardiologist Dr Sajad Reshi passes away
  1. PDP constitutes political affairs committee
  2. PDP constitutes political affairs committee
  1. Rail blockade at Chengail in West Bengal on Kathua rape case
  2. Rail blockade at Chengail in West Bengal on Kathua rape case
  1. SC seeks AG's help on media gag on CJI impeachment
  2. SC seeks AG's help on media gag on CJI impeachment
  1. Naroda Patiya massacre: Gujarat HC acquits ex-BJP minister Kodnani, convicts Babu Bajrangi
  2. Naroda Patiya massacre: Gujarat HC acquits ex-BJP minister Kodnani, convicts Babu Bajrangi
  1. JKLF Chief Yasin Malik detained in Srinagar
  2. JKLF Chief Yasin Malik detained in Srinagar
  1. Omar takes dig at Dy CM, accuses BJP of playing politics over Kathua rape and murder
  2. Omar takes dig at Dy CM, accuses BJP of playing politics over Kathua rape and murder
  1. Video | Fresh snowfall in higher reaches of Kashmir, rains lash plains
  2. Video | Fresh snowfall in higher reaches of Kashmir, rains lash plains
  1. Muslims observe shutdown in Chenab valley to demand speedy trial in Kathua case
  2. Muslims observe shutdown in Chenab valley to demand speedy trial in Kathua case
  1. Sonamarg-Zojila road closed for traffic after fresh snowfall
  2. Sonamarg-Zojila road closed for traffic after fresh snowfall
  1. UN staff increasingly becomes target of attack: Guterres
  2. UN staff increasingly becomes target of attack: Guterres
  1. Mughal road closed for traffic after landslide
  2. Mughal road closed for traffic after landslide
  1. Qatar approves draft law on property ownership by foreigners
  2. Qatar approves draft law on property ownership by foreigners
  1. Scientists find way to bend, stretch diamond
  2. Scientists find way to bend, stretch diamond