Experts find lacunae in machinery for Jhelum dredging

They cautioned about 2014 like disaster in making in case immediate measures are not taken to correct the messy dredging with suitable and effective equipments.

MUDASIR YAQOOB
Srinagar, Publish Date: May 20 2017 1:12AM | Updated Date: May 20 2017 1:12AM
Experts find lacunae in machinery for Jhelum dredgingFile Photo

Experts Friday pointed put various lacunae in the tender allocated to a Kolkata-based firm for dredging of river Jhelum and machinery pressed for execution of the project.

They cautioned about 2014 like disaster in making in case immediate measures are not taken to correct the messy dredging with suitable and effective equipments.

They said that September 2014 floods have proven beyond doubt the callous attitude of authorities in understanding the problems prior to augmenting solutions.

“One apprehends a major flood in the near future if corrective actions are not initiated on a war footing. Silt deposition can be seen all along the path from Khanabal, Sangam to Srinagar and in the event of an angry Jhelum, Pampore area and most of Srinagar’s areas are under immense threat as silt will be easily transported along the river bed slope due to high water velocity. The change in the water color denotes the excessive silt observed with expansion in the river width which rings alarming bells,” they cautioned.

They said that tender for dredging Jhelum allocated to Kolkata based firm have many lacunae. “I am amused to read the tender documents; Tender notice no. 17 of 2015-16 where to my knowledge several techno commercial errors have been committed at the tender stage,” said Munir Ahmad Mufti, a Kashmiri Mechanical Engineer presently working in Middle East with an international organization.

He said that the Trailer Suction Dredger (TSHD) which is presently pressed near Zero-Bridge can carry only fine silt or gravel “but surely cannot handle the slurry silt due to high viscosity unless added with sand.”

He said that he disagrees with the arguments or excuses by some authorities or executives that dredging is an uphill task to get the project executed on war footing keeping various negative factors including unpredictable weather conditions, governmental bottlenecks, level of expertise in managing and supervising such critical projects, availability of competent manpower, equipment resource and above all a positive cash flow in view.

“A comprehensive plan for segment dredging needs to be prioritized in order to ensure the right combination of marine equipment at the right location as the present operating dredgers are below capacity and exhibit low efficiency as has been proved by their poor performance over the years of operation. The dredger capacities shall further reduce due to presence of gravel, rocks, boulders in the silt and above all inexperienced operations staff which reduces the output,” he said.

“The tender requirements didn’t mention any technical submittal along with the commercial based on which the bidder would have been approved. It more or less shows that authorities are unaware of the procedures in dredging which require submittal of a detailed method statement, equipment list and qualified manpower to ensure the contractor is not experimenting while people suffer,” he said.

He said that authorities have still not woken up and are probably not aware of equipments and their capacities.

“Authorities still believe dredging about 150 cum/day would be a great challenge. Discharge distance of over 300 and 3000 and its implications on discharge output does not mean much of a difference to the authorities and the technical consultant appointed for the project, which proves beyond doubt they are all first timers and in experiment mode,” he said.

Referring to page 61 of the tender document, he said: “It amuses me to see the document precedence which is neither as per International Federation of Consulting Engineers (FIDIC) Green or Red book. I can assure the government and general masses that the contractor will have his say in the project and we will again have a blame game in place.”

Latest News

  1. Punjab Assembly in Pakistan unanimously adopts resolution, condemns killing of Hizb commander Sabzar Bhat
  2. Punjab Assembly in Pakistan unanimously adopts resolution, condemns killing of Hizb commander Sabzar Bhat
  1. Opposition slams Army Chief's comment on Kashmir protesters, govt defends him
  2. Opposition slams Army Chief's comment on Kashmir protesters, govt defends him
  1. Class work in Kashmir schools, colleges to remain suspended on May 30
  2. Class work in Kashmir schools, colleges to remain suspended on May 30
  1. Mehbooba asks tourism stakeholders to help clear negative perceptions on Kashmir
  2. Mehbooba asks tourism stakeholders to help clear negative perceptions on Kashmir
  1. China warns India over Dhola-Sadiya bridge in Arunachal
  2. China warns India over Dhola-Sadiya bridge in Arunachal
  1. Minor killed, man injured in two road accidents
  2. Minor killed, man injured in two road accidents
  1. Situation peaceful and under control throughout Kashmir: Police
  2. Situation peaceful and under control throughout Kashmir: Police
  1. Jadhav can never be released: Pakistani lawyer
  2. Jadhav can never be released: Pakistani lawyer
  1. Human shield case: Totally agree with Army chief's statement, says Naidu
  2. Human shield case: Totally agree with Army chief's statement, says Naidu
  1. Bring down the rhetoric: HC to Arnab Goswami, the Republic
  2. Bring down the rhetoric: HC to Arnab Goswami, the Republic
  1. T1 exam for Class 8th to be conducted internally: Altaf Bukhari
  2. T1 exam for Class 8th to be conducted internally: Altaf Bukhari
  1. IUST Awantipora postpones tomorrow’s exams, suspends class work
  2. IUST Awantipora postpones tomorrow’s exams, suspends class work
  1. Restrictions to continue in Srinagar parts tomorrow, educational institutions to remain closed
  2. Restrictions to continue in Srinagar parts tomorrow, educational institutions to remain closed
  1. Human shield case: Indian army chief showing 'criminal leadership', says Human Rights Watch
  2. Human shield case: Indian army chief showing 'criminal leadership', says Human Rights Watch
  1. Forces 'thrash' deranged man after he grabs trooper’s rifle in Anantnag
  2. Forces 'thrash' deranged man after he grabs trooper’s rifle in Anantnag
  1. NIA questions three Kashmiri separatist leaders in Delhi
  2. NIA questions three Kashmiri separatist leaders in Delhi
  1. Watch: Baby starts 'walking' moments after birth, video goes viral
  2. Watch: Baby starts 'walking' moments after birth, video goes viral
  1. IIT Madras students organise beef fest to protest cattle ban
  2. IIT Madras students organise beef fest to protest cattle ban
  1. Union Sports Minister rules out India-Pakistan cricket series
  2. Union Sports Minister rules out India-Pakistan cricket series
  1. Shopian shuts on eighth death anniversary of Aasiya, Neelofar
  2. Shopian shuts on eighth death anniversary of Aasiya, Neelofar
  1. North Korea test-fires another ballistic missile
  2. North Korea test-fires another ballistic missile
  1. Two boys die after consuming poison in Rajouri
  2. Two boys die after consuming poison in Rajouri
  1. Alert in Pathankot after army uniform found in suspicious bag
  2. Alert in Pathankot after army uniform found in suspicious bag
  1. Day 2: Curfew, restrictions continue in Kashmir
  2. Day 2: Curfew, restrictions continue in Kashmir