Panel intact, say legal experts

‘Just Members Need To Be Replaced’

Greater Kashmir
Publish Date: Oct 11 2012 12:00PM

Srinagar, Nov 9: While the Minister for PHE and Flood Control Taj Mohi-ud-Din reiterated his demand of quashing “illegal” House Committee probing forest land grab charges against him, legal experts Friday said the resignation of two National Conference legislators from the probe panel won’t impact its legal validity but the members need to be replaced.
“The committee is intact due to presence of majority of members. Three members are still there and only two have resigned,” said a legal expert. Pertinently, the House Committee was constituted under the chairmanship of Peoples Democratic Party legislator Murtaza Khan. Bashir Ahmed Magray of Congress, Syed Rafiq Shah of Panthers Party and NC legislators Khalid Najib Suharwardy and Bashir Ahmed Magray were appointed its members. Both the NC legislators resigned on Friday reportedly due to coalition compulsions. The lone Congress member Bashir Ahmad Magray is unlikely to resign, according to sources.
According to the experts, Chairman of the Council has to take a final call on the matter of replacements, being the custodian of the House. “The authority of inducting two new members lies with him,” they added.
Meanwhile, Taj said that the chairman of the Council derives power from the House and has to quash the Committee. “He gets power from the House and has to act as per the will of the House,” he said, adding that constitution of the panel against him was “illegal and unconstitutional.”
“The Upper House cannot inquire against the member of the Lower House and ordering inquiry against me by the LC chairman is first of its kind in the parliamentary history of the country,” he said.
“There is no such precedence,” he added.
Leader of the Upper House, R S Chib refused to comment on the matter. “What I had  to say I have written it in the letter,” he said.


Latest News

  1. BSF man killed in cross-border sniper fire in north Kashmir
  2. BSF man killed in cross-border sniper fire in north Kashmir
  1. Clashes erupt after forces launch search operation in Pulwama village
  2. Clashes erupt after forces launch search operation in Pulwama village
  1. Attacks on Kashmiri students: Minister visits Chandigarh University to assess the situation
  2. Attacks on Kashmiri students: Minister visits Chandigarh University to assess the situation
  1. South Kashmir: Militants attack forces' vehicle near air force station Malangpora
  2. South Kashmir: Militants attack forces' vehicle near air force station Malangpora
  1. Kashmir Editors Guild takes exception to NIA's 'new definition' of journalist, seeks Kamran Yousuf's release
  2. Kashmir Editors Guild takes exception to NIA's 'new definition' of journalist, seeks Kamran Yousuf's release
  1. Bureaucrats should be allowed to work freely: Rajnath
  2. Bureaucrats should be allowed to work freely: Rajnath
  1. Four Govt employees suspended in Kathua
  2. Four Govt employees suspended in Kathua
  1. Bar Association Baramulla condemns statement of Superintendent post office over shifting of proposed passport seva kendra
  2. Bar Association Baramulla condemns statement of Superintendent post office over shifting of proposed passport seva kendra
  1. BOSE to conduct 11th class exams from this year: Minister
  2. BOSE to conduct 11th class exams from this year: Minister
  1. Upset over being dropped, son of former Pakistani cricketer commits suicide
  2. Upset over being dropped, son of former Pakistani cricketer commits suicide
  1. Acute urban-rural divide in Internet penetration in India: Report
  2. Acute urban-rural divide in Internet penetration in India: Report
  1. Wreckage of crashed Iranian plane found in Isfahan
  2. Wreckage of crashed Iranian plane found in Isfahan
  1. Mob lynches two men accused of raping, killing minor in Arunachal Pradesh
  2. Mob lynches two men accused of raping, killing minor in Arunachal Pradesh
  1. Mild tremors felt in Jammu and Kashmir
  2. Mild tremors felt in Jammu and Kashmir
  1. Srinagar Central Jail a major hub for militant recruitment, says report by Jammu and Kashmir CID
  2. Srinagar Central Jail a major hub for militant recruitment, says report by Jammu and Kashmir CID
  1. SC to hear on bank top brass' role in PNB scam
  2. SC to hear on bank top brass' role in PNB scam
  1. China wooing Baloch militants to secure CPEC projects: Report
  2. China wooing Baloch militants to secure CPEC projects: Report
  1. New Delhi needs to explain Akhtar’s assertion about China’s involvement in Kashmir: Omar Abdullah
  2. New Delhi needs to explain Akhtar’s assertion about China’s involvement in Kashmir: Omar Abdullah
  1. India test fires medium range nuclear capable Agni-II missile
  2. India test fires medium range nuclear capable Agni-II missile
  1. Goa scribe quizzed over 'false news' on Parrikar's health
  2. Goa scribe quizzed over 'false news' on Parrikar's health
  1. UK, US in talks over two British militants
  2. UK, US in talks over two British militants
  1. PNB fraud: CBI continues questioning
  2. PNB fraud: CBI continues questioning
  1. SC to hear on bank top brass' role in PNB scam
  2. SC to hear on bank top brass' role in PNB scam
  1. Kashmir issue not limited to India and Pakistan only, China a major factor too: Naeem Akhtar
  2. Kashmir issue not limited to India and Pakistan only, China a major factor too: Naeem Akhtar
  1. Man bites snake in Uttar Pradesh
  2. Man bites snake in Uttar Pradesh
  1. Pak drug smuggler killed; 10 kg narcotics, arms seized along IB: BSF
  2. Pak drug smuggler killed; 10 kg narcotics, arms seized along IB: BSF
  1. Israeli minister meets Palestinian PM for peace talks
  2. Israeli minister meets Palestinian PM for peace talks
  1. Each year, six lakh newborns die within 28 days of birth in India: Study
  2. Each year, six lakh newborns die within 28 days of birth in India: Study