Muslims Appeasement: Myth or a Reality?

The issue is to be understood in a proper perspective

Sajad Ahmad Dar
Srinagar, Publish Date: Sep 12 2018 9:57PM | Updated Date: Sep 12 2018 9:57PM
Muslims Appeasement: Myth or a Reality?File Photo

Since 2014, the lynching of Muslims and Dalits has been a recurrent feature. While the silence on part of the government seems to empower the ‘gau-rakshaks’, (Mohsin Shaikh’s murder being the latest to the list in this regard), it also strengthens the belief that ‘Muslims in India are having the worst of their time since independence’ where they have been reduced to the second grade citizens. Yet putting the blame entirely on BJP is half the truth as Muslims in India have suffered equally if not more during the Emergency period and the Ayodhya dispute to say the least. The difference lies only in the form. The Opposition’s inability to question this culture (the ‘mob-culture’), probably fearing that it may hurt the sentiments of the majoritarian community, and thereby its vote-bank, further gives proof to this conviction that Muslims in India have not suffered less under the so called ‘Muslim friendly regimes’ who are in opposition today. However what is more worrying is that while the media (except a few T.V channels and Newspapers) barely gives coverage to this spate of cold-blooded murders, the civil societies have equally failed to condemn the ‘mob lynching’, except a few short-lived campaigns such as ‘Not in my name’.

The Muslims in India are generally yet quite wrongly believed to be ‘appeased’ by the Congress and the other ‘Secular Regimes’. This in turn has hurt them more than anything else; as it has given the Rightist forces a chance to bash the minority community (read Muslims). Sachar Committee Report in this direction is the newest yet finest example.  The Report which otherwise should have been an eye opener was instead projected by the BJP as a sort of ‘appeasement’ from Congress and SP. However, if we bother ourselves a bit and come out of our comfort zones and closely look into the history of this “appeasement” we will find that this “appeasement” is nothing but a myth. In fact Muslims in India have suffered equally if not more under the so called ‘Secular Regimes’. 

Nehruvian era was arguably a period of relative peace and communal harmony. This may be because of two reasons:

a) Legacy of national movement and the tall leadership of Nehru 

b) Or the electoral behavior during this period of time was more largely guided by the issues of security and physical protection after the trauma of partition. (Sudha Pai and Sajjan Kumar, 2018)

Yet it would be wrong to say that Nehru was successful in his action against communalism. Mushirul Hasan (1988) in this direction has rightly observed that Nehru did not ban communal parties and allowed the banning of cow slaughter in UP, Bihar, MP, and Rajasthan. All these states at that time were ruled by Congress party. One also fails to understand the logic behind the imposition of ban on RSS and then lifting it just a year and half later. 

Post Nehruvian period witnessed the alleged excesses of all sorts on Muslims (Sudha Pai and Sajjan Kumar, 2018). These state excesses also coincided with the growing political and economic aspirations of the Muslims whose concerns were from here on not only connected to the issues of security and protection. Congress, more particularly under Mrs. Indira Gandhi, during the 1980s made a conscious decision to shift to the right. Having lost the support of Muslims and Dalits during the emergency, she turned to the Hindus for support against the Muslims. Shahabuddin (1986) aptly sums up this oscillating behavior of Indira Gandhi “Mrs. Gandhi was ‘strategically secular’ and could be ‘tactically communal when the occasion so demanded’”. Her decision to build a Bharat Mata Temple was a well-calculated political move to create a Hindu vote bank. 

As if all this was not enough, Rajiv Gandhi deliberately embarked upon a policy of ‘soft Hindutva’. His constant reference to the Anandpur Sahib Resolution as a threat to the unity and integrity of the country appealed to the Hindus in north India which yielded rich dividends while the Muslims felt neglected (Sudha Pai and Sajjan Kumar 2018). Moreover the three controversies with communal overtones that happened during his tenure marked the retreat from secular politics.

a) Shah Bano Incident and Congress support to the conservative element.

b) Banning of “Satanic Verses” and the resultant riots in UP.

c) Finally the RJBBM dispute in which the Congress government acted as a mere spectator. 

Given this background blaming BJP for the communal disturbances and the woeful conditions of Muslims is just another way of exonerating the so called ‘Secular Regimes’ and Civil Societies. In fact SP has been involved in all the major riots of UP during the 2000s, and indulged in the competitive communalism(s) for narrow political gains (Sudha Pai and Sajjan Kumar, 2018). The SP government deliberately chose to turn a blind eye to the rising communal tension in a hope to win over Muslim support in 2014 National elections. It did not prevent either the Muzaffar Nagar riots nor were the effected provided with the adequate shelter. The state practically did nothing to punish the culprits who are rather roaming scot free. BSP is the only party under whose regime there have been no communal riots. However that too has been out of power since 2012, losing some of its support base to the BJP due to the Sub-alternization of Hindutva politics on part of Yogi and his HYV organistaion.

 

Sajad Ahmad Dar is pursuing doctorate from Centre of Advanced Study, Department of History, AMU, Aligarh. 

sajadakbar70@gmail.com

 

 

 

Latest News

  1. Jammu violence: JCCI accuses state administration of failing to take effective steps
  2. Jammu violence: JCCI accuses state administration of failing to take effective steps
  1. PDP stages protest in Srinagar urging Centre to ensure safety of Kashmiris
  2. PDP stages protest in Srinagar urging Centre to ensure safety of Kashmiris
  1. Governor’s advisor reviews security measures for students studying outside Jammu and Kashmir
  2. Governor’s advisor reviews security measures for students studying outside Jammu and Kashmir
  1. Don't attack innocent Kashmiris: CPI-M
  2. Don't attack innocent Kashmiris: CPI-M
  1. Kashmir colleges to remain closed until February 21: Div Com
  2. Kashmir colleges to remain closed until February 21: Div Com
  1. Pulwama attack: CRPF cautions people against fake pics aimed at spreading hatred
  2. Pulwama attack: CRPF cautions people against fake pics aimed at spreading hatred
  1. U'khand police asks Kashmiri students to not issue provocative statements, assures them safety
  2. U'khand police asks Kashmiri students to not issue provocative statements, assures them safety
  1. AMU issues advisory asking Kashmiri students not to move out of campus
  2. AMU issues advisory asking Kashmiri students not to move out of campus
  1. Shabir Shah was never provided security by govt: JKDFP
  2. Shabir Shah was never provided security by govt: JKDFP
  1. Move employees in Jammu urge governor to facilitate their journey back home
  2. Move employees in Jammu urge governor to facilitate their journey back home
  1. Fire raging in your bosoms is in my heart too: Modi on Pulwama attack
  2. Fire raging in your bosoms is in my heart too: Modi on Pulwama attack
  1. Banihal shuts against Jammu mob attacks
  2. Banihal shuts against Jammu mob attacks
  1. Attacking, terrorising Kashmiris outside JK will alienate them further: Omar Abdullah
  2. Attacking, terrorising Kashmiris outside JK will alienate them further: Omar Abdullah
  1. Withdrawing security not an issue for us, had never asked for it: Hurriyat (M)
  2. Withdrawing security not an issue for us, had never asked for it: Hurriyat (M)
  1. Pulwama attack fallout: Kashmiri students in Delhi fear for their security
  2. Pulwama attack fallout: Kashmiri students in Delhi fear for their security
  1. JK Governor announces Rs 20 lakh ex-gratia for kin of CRPF man killed in Pulwama attack
  2. JK Governor announces Rs 20 lakh ex-gratia for kin of CRPF man killed in Pulwama attack
  1. Mobile Internet service suspended in Kashmir
  2. Mobile Internet service suspended in Kashmir
  1. Valley shuts to protest attacks on Kashmiris in Jammu, other states
  2. Valley shuts to protest attacks on Kashmiris in Jammu, other states
  1. Pulwama attack fallout: Security cover of five Kashmiri separatist leaders withdrawn
  2. Pulwama attack fallout: Security cover of five Kashmiri separatist leaders withdrawn
  1. Four injured in leopard attack in south Kashmir’s Pulwama
  2. Four injured in leopard attack in south Kashmir’s Pulwama
  1. Move employees in Jammu to boycott duties from Monday, cite insecurity
  2. Move employees in Jammu to boycott duties from Monday, cite insecurity
  1. Four Kashmiri students of NIMS Rajasthan suspended over WhatsApp posts on Pulwama bombing
  2. Four Kashmiri students of NIMS Rajasthan suspended over WhatsApp posts on Pulwama bombing
  1. JNU students union urges state governments to prevent attacks on Kashmiri students
  2. JNU students union urges state governments to prevent attacks on Kashmiri students
  1. ICJ to hold public hearings in Kulbhushan Jadhav case from Feb 18
  2. ICJ to hold public hearings in Kulbhushan Jadhav case from Feb 18
  1. Guwahati teacher suspended for FB post blaming army for atrocities on civilians in Kashmir
  2. Guwahati teacher suspended for FB post blaming army for atrocities on civilians in Kashmir
  1. Army Major killed in Rajouri landmine explosion was to tie the knot next month
  2. Army Major killed in Rajouri landmine explosion was to tie the knot next month
  1. IUST Awantipora extends winter vacation until February 19
  2. IUST Awantipora extends winter vacation until February 19
  1. Divisional  Administration Kashmir establishes helpline
  2. Divisional Administration Kashmir establishes helpline
  1. JK children are being taken care of: Divisional Commissioner, Kashmir
  2. JK children are being taken care of: Divisional Commissioner, Kashmir
  1. Curfew continues in Jammu for third consecutive day
  2. Curfew continues in Jammu for third consecutive day
  1. Pulwama attack: MNS asks music companies to stop working with Pakistan singers
  2. Pulwama attack: MNS asks music companies to stop working with Pakistan singers
x
This site uses cookies to deliver our services and to show you relevant news and ads. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service.That's Fine