Cost of conflict

The cost that India is paying here is too high to be ignored by the Indian government and the Indian civil society.

Zahir-ud-Din
Srinagar, Publish Date: Jan 18 2019 11:14PM | Updated Date: Jan 18 2019 11:14PM
Cost of conflictFile Photo

A few days ago I received a video clip on my cell. It was a young boy aged 21 years arguing with an army officer, who as per the clip had abused him. The boy was furious and was repeatedly seeking an `explanation’ from the officer. “Why did you abuse me? When you leave Kashmir, you will hear similar abuses from us,” the angry boy made it clear to him. A decade ago, this was not possible. Nobody could argue with the men in uniform. And, this cannot be rejected as an isolated incident. A similar clip showed the heroics of a Sumo driver. He also gave an army man some tough moments.

There was a time when people, even those who had no connection with militancy, would run away from encounter sites. But the situation is totally different now. In contemporary Kashmir, people rush to encounter sites to help the militants flee, notwithstanding the pellets and bullets that are showered on them.

A few years ago, the state government released data which put the number of militants killed in two decades around twenty thousand. The data revealed that the conflict had also claimed around six thousand soldiers and officers of the armed forces. The ratio therefore is 1:4 roughly. A top army officer while travelling with my friend said the ratio was deadly.

The year bygone has been described as deadliest year of the decade by human rights groups. The Jammu Kashmir Coalition of Civil Society (JKCCS) in its annual report has informed that 267 militants died in 2018. The report says that 159 personnel of the armed forces also lost their lives during the same period. This includes 20 cases of fratricide as well. The ratio is alarming (1: 1.6). This means, while fighting un-trained militants, who get killed in fifteen minute encounters, the forces, considered the most experienced anti-insurgency force have suffered heavy casualties. This is what the analysis of the official data reveals. It is believed that the ratio in Afghanistan and Sri Lanka was mush lower. New Delhi has to do some serious thinking. The cost that India is paying here is too high to be ignored by the Indian government and the Indian civil society.

In the current month three fratricide cases have been reported and this reflects that there is something wrong somewhere. A social scientist while giving reasons for this phenomenon opined that the soldiers were suffering from PTSD, like ordinary people here. According to him, the prolonged conflict had taxed their nerves as well. He suggested counseling sessions for such soldiers and a break from routine work.

An army major from Srinagar’s Badami Bagh Cantonment termed the fratricide incidents as ‘noiseless self-executions’ in the army’s rank and file. He believes being a counter-insurgent might be a “much sought-after job” with incentives and benefits involved, but it comes with some unseen costs, the army major points out. “Our line of work is full of consequences. But for the sake of upholding the army’s pride, we often sweep the stress in our ranks under the carpet.” (The Wire Sep 29, 2017)

In early 90s, people were scared of the army but the times have changed now and so has the mindset in Kashmir. The presence of army makes no difference in contemporary Kashmir. The soldiers are treated the way people treat the police men.  During clashes at an encounter site in South Kashmir, the people almost manhandled the army men.

During a peace conference last year, a participant said that the Indian army had been reduced to a police force. Where will it end? The new generation that grew in the conflict is psychologically different. Unlike their seniors, they are not afraid of the army not to speak of para-military forces and the police.  And, if this is any indicator, the coming years are going to be tougher if tangible measures for resolution are not taken. The policy makers in New Delhi need to ponder.

A brief study by a human rights defender has held the police and the armed forces responsible for growing militancy in Kashmir. Most of the youth who joined militancy in the past three to four years are victims of custodial torture. However, this does not mean that the militants are out to avenge the atrocities they were subjected to. Indian experts ascribe the reason to growing alienation but the militants on the ground say they are there for very `sacred’ reasons. 

din.zahir@gmail.com

Latest News

  1. DIG South Kashmir Amit Kumar airlifted to AIIMS for treatment
  2. DIG South Kashmir Amit Kumar airlifted to AIIMS for treatment
  1. Authorities to impose restrictions in Srinagar parts tomorrow
  2. Authorities to impose restrictions in Srinagar parts tomorrow
  1. Div Com reviews stock position of essential commodities across valley
  2. Div Com reviews stock position of essential commodities across valley
  1. Forces launch searches in Bandipora village in north Kashmir
  2. Forces launch searches in Bandipora village in north Kashmir
  1. Punjab Police sets up helpline number for Kashmiris facing threats
  2. Punjab Police sets up helpline number for Kashmiris facing threats
  1. Our fight is for Kashmir, not against Kashmiris: Modi
  2. Our fight is for Kashmir, not against Kashmiris: Modi
  1. KEA condemns ‘pressure tactics’ against Greater Kashmir, KR
  2. KEA condemns ‘pressure tactics’ against Greater Kashmir, KR
  1. Nodal police officers appointed in all states, UTs for Kashmiris facing problems
  2. Nodal police officers appointed in all states, UTs for Kashmiris facing problems
  1. Amid tension, Pakistan Hindu MP calls for peace with India
  2. Amid tension, Pakistan Hindu MP calls for peace with India
  1. JRL calls shutdown tomorrow against mass arrests, assault on Article 35A
  2. JRL calls shutdown tomorrow against mass arrests, assault on Article 35A
  1. Delhi court defers hearing on separatist leader Shabir Shah's  bail plea till April 2
  2. Delhi court defers hearing on separatist leader Shabir Shah's bail plea till April 2
  1. Haryana man detained by police for shouting slogans at Srinagar's Lal Chowk
  2. Haryana man detained by police for shouting slogans at Srinagar's Lal Chowk
  1. Omar thanks PM Modi for speaking against attacks on Kashmiris
  2. Omar thanks PM Modi for speaking against attacks on Kashmiris
  1. Four CRPF personnel, five civilians injured in Baramulla road mishap
  2. Four CRPF personnel, five civilians injured in Baramulla road mishap
  1. BSF, ITBP to replace CRPF for static guard duties in Srinagar
  2. BSF, ITBP to replace CRPF for static guard duties in Srinagar
  1. NC protests against attacks on Kashmiris outside valley
  2. NC protests against attacks on Kashmiris outside valley
  1. Family members of Kulgam youth arrested in Deoband hold protest, demand his release
  2. Family members of Kulgam youth arrested in Deoband hold protest, demand his release
  1. Very, very dangerous situation between India and Pakistan: Trump
  2. Very, very dangerous situation between India and Pakistan: Trump
  1. 100 cars gutted in fire near Bengaluru air show
  2. 100 cars gutted in fire near Bengaluru air show
  1. Three shops, two cars damaged in mysterious Mendhar blaze
  2. Three shops, two cars damaged in mysterious Mendhar blaze
  1. Hit by boulders, two engineers die at Kishtwar construction site
  2. Hit by boulders, two engineers die at Kishtwar construction site
  1. Crackdown on Jamaat-e-Islami: 'Force', 'intimidation' will worsen situation, says Mirwaiz
  2. Crackdown on Jamaat-e-Islami: 'Force', 'intimidation' will worsen situation, says Mirwaiz
  1. Stopping advertisement to Greater Kashmir, Kashmir Reader attempt to manipulate news narrative: KCCI
  2. Stopping advertisement to Greater Kashmir, Kashmir Reader attempt to manipulate news narrative: KCCI
  1. Partial shutdown in city centre after mass arrests
  2. Partial shutdown in city centre after mass arrests
  1. Arrests of separatists, additional deployment of central police part of election exercise: Police
  2. Arrests of separatists, additional deployment of central police part of election exercise: Police
  1. Crackdown on Jama’at-e-Islami in Kashmir; party chief among 150 persons detained
  2. Crackdown on Jama’at-e-Islami in Kashmir; party chief among 150 persons detained
  1. Fifteen injured after truck turns turtle in Bandipora
  2. Fifteen injured after truck turns turtle in Bandipora
  1. Mehbooba, Sajjad Lone question crackdown on Jamaat-e-Islami Kashmir
  2. Mehbooba, Sajjad Lone question crackdown on Jamaat-e-Islami Kashmir
  1. Violent protests in Anantnag against thrashing of local youth in Chandigarh
  2. Violent protests in Anantnag against thrashing of local youth in Chandigarh
  1. Bandipora shuts after reports of killing of local militant in Sopore gunfight
  2. Bandipora shuts after reports of killing of local militant in Sopore gunfight
  1. Man injured after avalanche hits Ajas in north Kashmir
  2. Man injured after avalanche hits Ajas in north Kashmir
  1. Centre to 'urgently' deploy 100 more companies of central armed forces in Kashmir
  2. Centre to 'urgently' deploy 100 more companies of central armed forces in Kashmir
  1. Kashmir highway partially restored
  2. Kashmir highway partially restored
x
This site uses cookies to deliver our services and to show you relevant news and ads. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service.That's Fine