Former Indian army general says army made way for government to resolve Kashmir, but politics failed

In his column, Panag claimed both the insurgents and the government have a political aim and evolve a political strategy, which drives their military strategy.

GK Web Desk
Srinagar, Publish Date: Dec 6 2018 2:01PM | Updated Date: Dec 6 2018 2:11PM
Former Indian army general says army made way for government to resolve Kashmir, but politics failedFile photo used for representation

A former army general has said the army had created an environment to resolve Kashmir but the elected governments failed to find any solution to the vexed issue.

Lt Gen (Retd) H S Panag, who was posted as GOC of the army's Northern Command, Udhampur in Jammu and Kashmir, wrote in The Print that the “unpopular coalition government could not provide the healing touch in Jammu and Kashmir.”

In his column, Panag claimed both the insurgents and the government have a political aim and evolve a political strategy, which drives their military strategy.

“Both strive to win the hearts and minds of the people to garner their support,” he said.

“The current situation in Jammu and Kashmir, particularly in the Valley, is a classic example of our dithering political strategy,” he wrote in the article.

Panag putting his argument over the resolution of vexed Kashmir issue said the Indian Army had created an enabling environment for politics to take centre stage and resolve the problem. “Politics did come to the fore, but instead of a solution we saw the revival of the insurgency,” he said.

While quoting military theorist Carl von Clausewitz, who has said that ‘war is not a performance of senseless passion, but is controlled by political objective’ the former general said this is equally true for an insurgency.

“Insurgents use force to undermine the state’s authority and to coerce the population to toe their line. The government, on the other hand, uses force to neutralise the insurgents and ensure that its writ runs in the state to bring about economic well-being of the people and resolve their political grievances,” Panag said.

He said once a conducive environment has been created, politics must take centre stage and military must fade into the background.

“There are some historical examples where predominantly force or military means have been used to neutralise insurgencies. However, the same is not possible in a multi-cultural, multi-religious and multi-lingual democracy like India,” he concluded.

Latest News

  1. An MLA was told to be part of govt or prepare for arrest by NIA: Omar Abdullah on horse-trading
  2. An MLA was told to be part of govt or prepare for arrest by NIA: Omar Abdullah on horse-trading
  1. Disgruntled Muzaffar Baig holds meeting with Mehbooba Mufti
  2. Disgruntled Muzaffar Baig holds meeting with Mehbooba Mufti
  1. Vijay Mallya must be extradited: London court
  2. Vijay Mallya must be extradited: London court
  1. BJP built tallest statue of Patel, but could not construct Ram temple: Omar Abdullah
  2. BJP built tallest statue of Patel, but could not construct Ram temple: Omar Abdullah
  1. RBI Governor Urjit Patel quits
  2. RBI Governor Urjit Patel quits
  1. Former MLA Tangmarg Abbas Wani resigns from PDP
  2. Former MLA Tangmarg Abbas Wani resigns from PDP
  1. Renowned historian and former Jamia Millia VC Mushirul Hasan passes away
  2. Renowned historian and former Jamia Millia VC Mushirul Hasan passes away
  1. JRL writes to UN chief, urges him to establish commission of inquiry into Kashmir rights abuses
  2. JRL writes to UN chief, urges him to establish commission of inquiry into Kashmir rights abuses
  1. Human Rights Day: Mirwaiz seeks help of world community to end Kashmir rights violations
  2. Human Rights Day: Mirwaiz seeks help of world community to end Kashmir rights violations
  1. On Human Rights Day, relatives of disappeared persons protest in Srinagar
  2. On Human Rights Day, relatives of disappeared persons protest in Srinagar
  1. India test fires Agni-V missile
  2. India test fires Agni-V missile
  1. Kushwaha quits NDA, resigns as Minister
  2. Kushwaha quits NDA, resigns as Minister
  1. Woman dies after falling from Ferris wheel at UP fair while clicking selfie
  2. Woman dies after falling from Ferris wheel at UP fair while clicking selfie
  1. Two drug peddlers arrested in Jammu and Kashmir's Rajouri
  2. Two drug peddlers arrested in Jammu and Kashmir's Rajouri
  1. Modi govt considers farmers as liability: Rahul Gandhi
  2. Modi govt considers farmers as liability: Rahul Gandhi
  1. JRL calls shutdown in poll-bound areas of Kashmir on Tuesday
  2. JRL calls shutdown in poll-bound areas of Kashmir on Tuesday
  1. BJP expels dissident leader after SC junks his plea against governor’s decision to dissolve JK legislative assembly
  2. BJP expels dissident leader after SC junks his plea against governor’s decision to dissolve JK legislative assembly
  1. Indian diplomat walks out of SAARC meeting in Pakistan over PaK minister's presence
  2. Indian diplomat walks out of SAARC meeting in Pakistan over PaK minister's presence
  1. UP woman locked inside home by son, dies of hunger: police
  2. UP woman locked inside home by son, dies of hunger: police
  1. Clashes erupt in Hajin after burial of slain teenage militants
  2. Clashes erupt in Hajin after burial of slain teenage militants
  1. Thousands attend funeral of slain teenage militants in north Kashmir’s Hajin
  2. Thousands attend funeral of slain teenage militants in north Kashmir’s Hajin
  1. SC dismisses former BJP legislator's plea challenging dissolution of Jammu and Kashmir Assembly
  2. SC dismisses former BJP legislator's plea challenging dissolution of Jammu and Kashmir Assembly
  1. India beat Australia by 31 runs in Adelaide Test
  2. India beat Australia by 31 runs in Adelaide Test
  1. Brexit deal: Theresa May faces fight for her political life on Tuesday
  2. Brexit deal: Theresa May faces fight for her political life on Tuesday
  1. Role of military limited, solution of Kashmir issue only through politics: Army commander
  2. Role of military limited, solution of Kashmir issue only through politics: Army commander
  1. Kashmir shuts on JRL call against human rights violations
  2. Kashmir shuts on JRL call against human rights violations
  1. Pakistan continues to harbour militants that turn around and kill American soldiers: Nikki Haley
  2. Pakistan continues to harbour militants that turn around and kill American soldiers: Nikki Haley
  1. 'I can't breathe', Jamal Khashoggi's last words at Saudi consulate
  2. 'I can't breathe', Jamal Khashoggi's last words at Saudi consulate
  1. Mughal road, Srinagar-Leh highway closed after fresh snowfall in Kashmir
  2. Mughal road, Srinagar-Leh highway closed after fresh snowfall in Kashmir
x
This site uses cookies to deliver our services and to show you relevant news and ads. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service.That's Fine