Curious Case of Article 35-A

We need to defend our case strongly and logically

Shahnawaz Ellahi
Srinagar, Publish Date: Aug 9 2018 11:32PM | Updated Date: Aug 9 2018 11:32PM
Curious Case of Article 35-AFile Photo

There is a new threat looming all over the state. The constitutional validity of the covenant Article 35-A has been put into question by a little known NGO called We The Citizens and a think tank called Kashmir Study Centre who have challenged the “provision” in the Apex Court, which it argues was enacted without any debate in the parliament. It has caused fear and resentment yet again and Kashmir seems to be all set for the next bigger uprising which according to some senior state politicians would be difficult even for the centre to contain.

Peeping into the history of Article 35-A, we find its emergence in the 1927 Hereditary State Subject Order passed by Maharaja after the pandit community launched the “Kashmir for the Kashmiri” movement. This order granted to the “state subjects”, the right to government office and the right to land use and ownership. After the accession of Jammu and Kashmir to the Indian Union, the Maharaja ceded the hitherto sovereign subjects of Defence, External Affairs and Communication to the Government of India formalising it by means of Article 370 of the Constitution Of India. This was followed by the Delhi Agreement in 1952 whereby the Indian government agreed that the state of J&K would be empowered to legislate over the rights and privileges of the “state subjects” who would now be called as “permanent residents”.

Following the adoption of the provisions of the Delhi Agreement by the Constituent Assembly of J&K, the President of India issued “The Constitution (Application to Jammu And Kashmir) Order”, 1954 which inserted the Article 35-A into the Indian constitution enabling the state legislature to ‘safeguard the laws’ defining the privileges of the permanent residents. 

Contrary to the belief that Article 35-A ‘directly’ gave special privileges to the “permanent residents”, it actually safeguarded the laws that had been and were promised to remain the sovereign functions of the state of Jammu And Kashmir. In other words, it was the state that had extended special rights to the Government of India by ceding some of its sovereign functions. Also if we look into the following provisions of the Presidential Order of 1954, we can see that the issue is no more than a political controversy and the honourable Supreme Court will take a fair and square decision on it:-

1) Indian citizenship was extended to the “permanent residents” of Jammu and Kashmir.

3) The jurisdiction of the Supreme Court of India was extended to the state.

Therefore if the “Presidential order” is declared null and void by the Supreme Court, then the “permanent residents” will no more be citizens of India and the act will also raise questions on the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court in the state.

Further, the Supreme Court will also have to annul all the Presidential Orders which followed the order of 1954 in the form of amendments to the original Order and which have been accused of being the prime instrument to erode the sacrosanct Article 370. These orders are nothing but the constitutional links between Indian Union and the State and abrogation of these orders should theoretically, restore the position of the state to the status preceding the accession to India. 

The Supreme Court on 6th August said,” We will only have to see whether Article 35-A goes against the basic structure of Constitution”. The doctrine of basic structure of the constitution is an innovation by the Supreme Court which took place during the famous case of Kesavananda Bharati 1973 where it ruled that the power of parliament to amend the constitution under Article 368 does not enable it to alter the basic structure of the constitution. Again two perspectives emerge:

a) The doctrine clearly states that it can be applied to the amendments made by the parliament under Article 368 which is not the case of Article 35-A as it was neither amended by parliament nor inserted by taking recourse to Article 368.

b) The Supreme Court also made it clear that the doctrine would apply only to the amendment enacted after April 24 1973 (i.e. the date of the judgement in the Kesvananda Bharti case) therefore saving the Article 35-A (which was enacted much earlier) from judicial review under this doctrine.

Everything said and done, the logical and simple explanation for the Presidential Order of 1954 not coming through the way of deliberation in the Parliament is that the sovereign state of Jammu And Kashmir acceded to India in October 1947 through the execution of the “Instrument of Accession” which allowed Indian Parliament to make laws for the state of J&K only in respect of Defence, Communication and External Affairs, thus limiting its powers with respect to other subjects of the State. Matter of fact is that India recognises the separate constitution of the state of Jammu and Kashmir and so even if Article 35-A is repealed, it does not take away the power of the state to define its “permanent residents” or to give them rights which are not extended to “non-residents”.

 

As for the women alleging that their rights in property has been denied after they married non-residents, it can be said that it does not amount to total denial of property as the assets in the jurisdiction of the state can be liquidated and transferred to the daughter. However their concern is genuine and the state government needs to take appropriate measure through the course of law to redress the grievances without getting into the issue of Article 35-A. As of now, strong arguments should be prepared by the state in its defence and people should have full faith in the learned and competent council representing our state in the Apex Court on 27th of August.

 

 

(Author can be reached at ishahnawazassad@gmail.com)

 

Latest News

  1. Class work to remain suspended at Kashmir University on Friday
  2. Class work to remain suspended at Kashmir University on Friday
  1. Classwork to remain suspended in Srinagar colleges, higher secondary schools on Friday
  2. Classwork to remain suspended in Srinagar colleges, higher secondary schools on Friday
  1. Army says transgressions down along LAC in Ladakh
  2. Army says transgressions down along LAC in Ladakh
  1. Dr Kunzes Dolma given charge of Director Health Services Kashmir
  2. Dr Kunzes Dolma given charge of Director Health Services Kashmir
  1. No move to deploy 'Black Cat' commandos in Jammu and Kashmir: Guv Malik
  2. No move to deploy 'Black Cat' commandos in Jammu and Kashmir: Guv Malik
  1. CBI begins probe in Jammu and Kashmir arms licence case
  2. CBI begins probe in Jammu and Kashmir arms licence case
  1. Ram temple row: RSS, BJP do not believe in 'pluralism', says Owaisi
  2. Ram temple row: RSS, BJP do not believe in 'pluralism', says Owaisi
  1. Former UP, Uttarakhand CM N D Tiwari dead
  2. Former UP, Uttarakhand CM N D Tiwari dead
  1. Extending 73rd, 74th amendments direct attack on Art 370: NC
  2. Extending 73rd, 74th amendments direct attack on Art 370: NC
  1. Pak's SC dismisses PML-N leader's petition seeking Imran Khan's disqualification
  2. Pak's SC dismisses PML-N leader's petition seeking Imran Khan's disqualification
  1. Court takes cognisance of Akbar's defamation case, his statement to be recorded on Oct 31
  2. Court takes cognisance of Akbar's defamation case, his statement to be recorded on Oct 31
  1. BJP hits back after Azad says lesser number of Hindu candidates invite him for campaigning
  2. BJP hits back after Azad says lesser number of Hindu candidates invite him for campaigning
  1. Modi's cronyism putting IAF pilots at risk: Rahul
  2. Modi's cronyism putting IAF pilots at risk: Rahul
  1. Ex-BSP MP's son surrenders, arrested for waving pistol at hotel
  2. Ex-BSP MP's son surrenders, arrested for waving pistol at hotel
  1. PDD lineman electrocuted to death in Budgam village
  2. PDD lineman electrocuted to death in Budgam village
  1. Man gives 'triple talaq' to wife via WhatsApp, booked
  2. Man gives 'triple talaq' to wife via WhatsApp, booked
  1. #MeToo movement launched by people with 'perverted' minds: BJP minister
  2. #MeToo movement launched by people with 'perverted' minds: BJP minister
  1. One dead, three injured after bus carrying pilgrims meets accident in Katra
  2. One dead, three injured after bus carrying pilgrims meets accident in Katra
  1. Govt says no threat of discontinuation of mobile numbers issued using Aadhaar
  2. Govt says no threat of discontinuation of mobile numbers issued using Aadhaar
  1. Armed struggle 'only option' to resolve Kashmir dispute: Salahuddin
  2. Armed struggle 'only option' to resolve Kashmir dispute: Salahuddin
  1. 2G Internet service restored in Kashmir capital Srinagar
  2. 2G Internet service restored in Kashmir capital Srinagar
  1. Saudi suspect in Khashoggi case killed in accident: Turkish daily
  2. Saudi suspect in Khashoggi case killed in accident: Turkish daily
  1. Tehreek-ul-Mujahideen militant laid to rest in Awantipora amid pro-freedom slogans
  2. Tehreek-ul-Mujahideen militant laid to rest in Awantipora amid pro-freedom slogans
  1. Internet remains suspended in Kashmir capital for second straight day
  2. Internet remains suspended in Kashmir capital for second straight day
  1. MJ Akbar’s resignation result of women journalists’ courage: Editors Guild of India
  2. MJ Akbar’s resignation result of women journalists’ courage: Editors Guild of India
  1. RSS chief Bhagwat pitches for legally constructing Ram temple
  2. RSS chief Bhagwat pitches for legally constructing Ram temple
  1. Turkish police search Saudi consulate again in Khashoggi case
  2. Turkish police search Saudi consulate again in Khashoggi case
  1. Militant arrested by police in Pattan an innocent student: Tehreek-ul-Mujahideen
  2. Militant arrested by police in Pattan an innocent student: Tehreek-ul-Mujahideen
  1. 116 policemen suspended over 2014 firing in Pakistan
  2. 116 policemen suspended over 2014 firing in Pakistan
  1. Protests rock Kashmir University against killing of student-turned-militant in Pulwama
  2. Protests rock Kashmir University against killing of student-turned-militant in Pulwama
  1. Shutdown, restrictions paralyse life in Kashmir
  2. Shutdown, restrictions paralyse life in Kashmir
  1. Man sentenced to more than 24 years for Texas mosque fire
  2. Man sentenced to more than 24 years for Texas mosque fire
  1. US teenager baked grandfather's ashes into cookies: police
  2. US teenager baked grandfather's ashes into cookies: police
  1. Pre-order iPhone XR in India from Friday
  2. Pre-order iPhone XR in India from Friday
  1. Trump denies cover up allegations, seeks full report on Khashoggi
  2. Trump denies cover up allegations, seeks full report on Khashoggi
  1. Newly-recruited militant killed in brief shootout in Pulwama
  2. Newly-recruited militant killed in brief shootout in Pulwama
x
This site uses cookies to deliver our services and to show you relevant news and ads. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service.That's Fine