Lynching: horrendous act of mobocracy

…Swami Agnivesh episode marks the new low

Dr. Javid Iqbal
Srinagar, Publish Date: Jul 20 2018 11:35PM | Updated Date: Jul 20 2018 11:35PM
Lynching: horrendous act of mobocracyFile Photo

Lynching was labelled as “horrendous act of mobocracy” in Tuesday’s Supreme Court ruling. However, even before the ink had dried on the ruling, Swami Agnivesh was attacked in Jharkhand by a mob, allegedly of Bharatiya Janata Yuva Morcha (BJYM) activists, affiliated to BJP. From cow-vigilantes lynching Muslim suspected of eating beef to Dalits engaged in the beef-trade and now to Swami Agnivesh supporting the softer face of Hinduism, India has come a long way.  The lynching trend started with BJP gaining power in the federal Indian government and in vast swathes of cow belt. The hold over federal and many state governments emboldened front organizations of Hindutva to launch a frontal attack on marginalized communities. It has resulted in killings, grievous injuries too, to many victims of vigilante terror. The fear psychosis in minorities is deepening by the day.

Judicial intervention over the on-going week marks the inability of the political executive in the federal government and state governments to check the menace.  Supreme Court three member bench headed by Chief Justice Dipak Misra passed stringent comments, urging the parliament to enact a separate law to deal with mob lynching so that “fear of law and veneration for the command of law constitute the foundation of a civilized society”. The 45 page verdict of the Apex Court further read, “The horrendous acts of mobocracy cannot be permitted to inundate the law of the land. Earnest action and concrete steps have to be taken to protect the citizens from the recurrent pattern of violence, which cannot be allowed to become the new normal”

The judicial note that it cannot be allowed to become “the new normal” is an admission of sorts that the political executive has allowed to become “the new normal” by not only failing to act, but by being passive accomplices.  Union Minister—Jayant Sinha felicitated eight men convicted in the lynching to death of Alimuddin Ansari in Ramgarh town of Jharkhand on June, the 29th 2017. 12 people were convicted by a fast track court. Subsequently, 8 persons were released on bail by Jharkhand High Court citing ‘’lack of evidence of specific assault.’’ On July, the 7th Jayant Sinha welcomed the convicts with garlands and sweets. Apart from others, the gruesome act of the Union Minister was condemned by his father, Yashwant Sinha—former minister of finance and external affairs. Union ministers seemingly endorsing acts of lynching help make it the “new normal’’ pointedly referred to by the Apex Court. 

In the same state—Jharkhand, the lynching that 80 year old Swami Agnivesh had to face was shamelessly labelled by CP Singh—urban development minister, as self-engineered to gain publicity. The minister called Swami ‘’A Fraud’’ wanting more money. CP Singh is a minister in the same government that has ordered an enquiry in the Swami lynching episode, as such he was pre-judging the issue still under investigation. In a situation, where minister at the level of federal government and in the states take a stance that favours the brigades let loose by extremist forces, it is bound to assume the shape of the ‘’new normal.’’ And, it becomes doubtful whether judicial intervention would lead to positive results. In fact, even before the Supreme Court hearing over the on-going week, the courts were moved and the lynching was commented upon adversely.

It was last year in September that the Apex Court asked all the states to take stern measures to stop violence in the name of cow protection. The court directive implied appointment of senior police officers as nodal officers in every district within a week in order to check cow vigilantes from taking "law unto themselves.’’ The court had gone as far as to seek response from Rajasthan, Haryana and Uttar Pradesh governments. Cow vigilantism however continued in one form or another, evidence that the grave issue has gone beyond the realms of effective judicial intervention. Earlier in July, in fact on July 3, three member bench of Supreme Court reserved its verdict on pleas to initiate contempt against states that failed to take measures to combat cow vigilantism. The states named were the ones, where maximum number of cases has been recorded, namely Rajasthan, Haryana and Uttar Pradesh. Tushar Gandhi—Mahatma Gandhi’s grandson pleaded that contempt proceedings must be initiated against these states, for failure to comply with court’s orders. In the present instance however, over the week, it has been reported that Apex Court has directed the states to file a compliance report within four weeks. The next hearing is slated for August, the 20th.  

The judicial directive in the present instance seems to be an inclusive of preventive, remedial and punitive measures. This includes asking the state governments to prevent dissemination of “irresponsible and explosive” messages, videos and other material across social media platforms and work in coordination to prevent lynching. It is also implied that penal consequences for lynching may be made known by the Centre and state governments by broadcasting across all media platforms. It is to be seen whether preventive measures suggested, remedies pointed out and the warnings of punitive measures is going to affect what certain quarters are bent upon making out the ‘’new normal’’. Judicial intervention might not be enough, unless it is augmented by political will of the powers that be. Ground factors suggest that the needed will is lacking, hence the question mark over judicial intervention.  

Yaar Zinda, Sohbat Baqi [Reunion is subordinate to survival]

 

Latest News

  1. Class work to remain suspended at Kashmir University on Friday
  2. Class work to remain suspended at Kashmir University on Friday
  1. Classwork to remain suspended in Srinagar colleges, higher secondary schools on Friday
  2. Classwork to remain suspended in Srinagar colleges, higher secondary schools on Friday
  1. Army says transgressions down along LAC in Ladakh
  2. Army says transgressions down along LAC in Ladakh
  1. Dr Kunzes Dolma given charge of Director Health Services Kashmir
  2. Dr Kunzes Dolma given charge of Director Health Services Kashmir
  1. No move to deploy 'Black Cat' commandos in Jammu and Kashmir: Guv Malik
  2. No move to deploy 'Black Cat' commandos in Jammu and Kashmir: Guv Malik
  1. CBI begins probe in Jammu and Kashmir arms licence case
  2. CBI begins probe in Jammu and Kashmir arms licence case
  1. Ram temple row: RSS, BJP do not believe in 'pluralism', says Owaisi
  2. Ram temple row: RSS, BJP do not believe in 'pluralism', says Owaisi
  1. Former UP, Uttarakhand CM N D Tiwari dead
  2. Former UP, Uttarakhand CM N D Tiwari dead
  1. Extending 73rd, 74th amendments direct attack on Art 370: NC
  2. Extending 73rd, 74th amendments direct attack on Art 370: NC
  1. Pak's SC dismisses PML-N leader's petition seeking Imran Khan's disqualification
  2. Pak's SC dismisses PML-N leader's petition seeking Imran Khan's disqualification
  1. Court takes cognisance of Akbar's defamation case, his statement to be recorded on Oct 31
  2. Court takes cognisance of Akbar's defamation case, his statement to be recorded on Oct 31
  1. BJP hits back after Azad says lesser number of Hindu candidates invite him for campaigning
  2. BJP hits back after Azad says lesser number of Hindu candidates invite him for campaigning
  1. Modi's cronyism putting IAF pilots at risk: Rahul
  2. Modi's cronyism putting IAF pilots at risk: Rahul
  1. Ex-BSP MP's son surrenders, arrested for waving pistol at hotel
  2. Ex-BSP MP's son surrenders, arrested for waving pistol at hotel
  1. PDD lineman electrocuted to death in Budgam village
  2. PDD lineman electrocuted to death in Budgam village
  1. Man gives 'triple talaq' to wife via WhatsApp, booked
  2. Man gives 'triple talaq' to wife via WhatsApp, booked
  1. #MeToo movement launched by people with 'perverted' minds: BJP minister
  2. #MeToo movement launched by people with 'perverted' minds: BJP minister
  1. One dead, three injured after bus carrying pilgrims meets accident in Katra
  2. One dead, three injured after bus carrying pilgrims meets accident in Katra
  1. Govt says no threat of discontinuation of mobile numbers issued using Aadhaar
  2. Govt says no threat of discontinuation of mobile numbers issued using Aadhaar
  1. Armed struggle 'only option' to resolve Kashmir dispute: Salahuddin
  2. Armed struggle 'only option' to resolve Kashmir dispute: Salahuddin
  1. 2G Internet service restored in Kashmir capital Srinagar
  2. 2G Internet service restored in Kashmir capital Srinagar
  1. Saudi suspect in Khashoggi case killed in accident: Turkish daily
  2. Saudi suspect in Khashoggi case killed in accident: Turkish daily
  1. Tehreek-ul-Mujahideen militant laid to rest in Awantipora amid pro-freedom slogans
  2. Tehreek-ul-Mujahideen militant laid to rest in Awantipora amid pro-freedom slogans
  1. Internet remains suspended in Kashmir capital for second straight day
  2. Internet remains suspended in Kashmir capital for second straight day
  1. MJ Akbar’s resignation result of women journalists’ courage: Editors Guild of India
  2. MJ Akbar’s resignation result of women journalists’ courage: Editors Guild of India
  1. RSS chief Bhagwat pitches for legally constructing Ram temple
  2. RSS chief Bhagwat pitches for legally constructing Ram temple
  1. Turkish police search Saudi consulate again in Khashoggi case
  2. Turkish police search Saudi consulate again in Khashoggi case
  1. Militant arrested by police in Pattan an innocent student: Tehreek-ul-Mujahideen
  2. Militant arrested by police in Pattan an innocent student: Tehreek-ul-Mujahideen
  1. 116 policemen suspended over 2014 firing in Pakistan
  2. 116 policemen suspended over 2014 firing in Pakistan
  1. Protests rock Kashmir University against killing of student-turned-militant in Pulwama
  2. Protests rock Kashmir University against killing of student-turned-militant in Pulwama
  1. Shutdown, restrictions paralyse life in Kashmir
  2. Shutdown, restrictions paralyse life in Kashmir
  1. Man sentenced to more than 24 years for Texas mosque fire
  2. Man sentenced to more than 24 years for Texas mosque fire
  1. US teenager baked grandfather's ashes into cookies: police
  2. US teenager baked grandfather's ashes into cookies: police
  1. Pre-order iPhone XR in India from Friday
  2. Pre-order iPhone XR in India from Friday
  1. Trump denies cover up allegations, seeks full report on Khashoggi
  2. Trump denies cover up allegations, seeks full report on Khashoggi
  1. Newly-recruited militant killed in brief shootout in Pulwama
  2. Newly-recruited militant killed in brief shootout in Pulwama
x
This site uses cookies to deliver our services and to show you relevant news and ads. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service.That's Fine