An open letter to Modi

Being a non-residential Indian, I hadn''t known or heard much about the situation here in Kashmir, and what happens here on the ground level.
An open letter to Modi
File Photo

Dear Mr Prime Minister. I'm an ordinary 17 year old girl, recently graduated from high school. I came to Kashmir on the 10th of July to visit my hometown along with my family, where all my relatives were eagerly waiting to congratulate me. Being a non-residential Indian, I hadn't known or heard much about the situation here in Kashmir, and what happens here on the ground level. However, once I got off the plane, all of that was going to change. Right after we reached here, none of my relatives were able to take us from the airport. The roads were deserted, none dared to look out of their houses. It took us over a day to reach our home. And right after that, for the next week (and counting) we're under house arrest. No communication with either the outside world, or even my relatives within the borders Kashmir whom I hadn't seen for over a year. I've read about war-like situations in my history books but I couldn't even fathom I'd be a witness to it from my own home. 

Mr PM, the Army is encircling our neighbourhood with their big guns, children screaming out protests for their voices to be heard, stones held against tear-gas bombs, all streaming live outside our gates. My little siblings are peeking through windows, tears brimming out of their eyes distraught in fear. What do I tell them? That we cannot meet our cousins who live ten minutes away from us? That they cant buy their favourite sweets from shops because everything is on lockdown? That there's serious political and humanitarian crisis going on outside our four walls? How do I tell them that there's innocent people dying and succumbing to injuries? How do I tell them there's a scarcity of resources and funding in hospitals for patients, yet apparently there's enough money to send in more Army and get ammunition? How do I tell them the people here seem so fed up they run out of their houses to express their searing pain with stones and pebbles, well aware that they'll be receiving bullets in return? How to I tell them that despite the cries and protests and hails and strikes-their voices aren't being heard? How can I tell them, this is all because of one simple, profound, and ugly truth. Everyone wants Kashmir, but no one cares for Kashmiris. Because if we cared for Kashmiris, we wouldn't care of people's opinion on whether Burhan Wani was a terrorist or a martyr, we'd try to understand why a topper student chose to continue his career holding a gun rather than a pen. If we cared for Kashmiris, we wouldn't throw in money to strengthen the army count in the valley, we'd send money to hospitals and families whose innocent children were brutally killed and injured, those victims of pellets and tear gases only because they were in the wrong place at the wrong time. If we cared for Kashmiris, we'd take the civilians as seriously as the media did for the tourists and people going for the Amarnath Yatra. If we cared for Kashmiris, Indian press wouldn't call them 'Kashmiris', they'd call them 'Indians'. 

Mr PM, if we cared for Kashmiris, we wouldn't find ways to turn off all communications in the valley only to further deprive them of freedom, we'd open up all means for their voices to be heard. Because isn't that all Kashmiris are asking for? 

Mr PM, I see the newsflash, the attack in Nice, France is screened followed by the attempted military coup in Turkey, along with the report on the monsoon rains in southern India. But where is the news on Kashmir? Is this why I never knew what was going on in my hometown for such a long time, Sir? It's a little ironic, but do we call Kashmir a valley because we're surrounded by mountains, or because we're completely isolated from the outside world? There are too many questions in my head, too less people who care to answer. Why is that, Sir Prime Minister? 

Regardless, amidst this chaos, I realise one thing, Sir. I do not care whether this is the Army's fault, or the militants', when we are given too much power, we easily become corrupt. I do not care about the political clashes going on in your upper echelons, this is still outside the level of comprehension for an ordinary 17 year old girl. I do not care whether the Kashmiri wants to stay in India, become part of Pakistan, or become a sovereign country. All I care is that when people look at Kashmir, they don't just see the beautiful mountains, they see those innocent lives being beaten to death amidst continuous reasonless clashes. When people look at Kashmir, they don't just look at the fertile lands, but the people being muted even with the loudest screams for their voices to be heard by India, by the world. When people look at Kashmir, they don't just see the Dal lake overlooked by the lush mughal gardens, but the screams of children being subjected to pellets, and now lying in an underpaid hospital with no resources to treat them. I'm sure, Mr Prime Minister, there's effort work being done by the ministries and government to fix the situation here, but nothing has been done so far, as if all leaders have been silenced and nobody is ready to make a change. The demands Kashmiris are yearning for might be outside what we can offer, but at least we can try to help them? Listen to them? Take them seriously? Reason with them? Kashmiris have been ignored for far too long, whether it is by NRI's like me who didn't have an inkling clue about the situation here, or by Indians all over the country, who seem to see Kashmir "full of militants and always having problems", or by the people of the world, who have other problems on their plates. Or maybe after years of disturbances and fights and deaths in this region, we have become desensitized to the pain Kashmiris are subjected to on a daily basis. 

Please don't get me wrong Sir Prime Minister, I'm not placing anyone at fault here. I know India, the biggest democracy in the world, is a country with an excellent economic growth, promising scientific and technological advancements, beautiful cultural diversity (which Kashmir plays a vital role in) but why can it not simply accept Kashmiris rather than treating them as a mistrusted adopted child? Some children can go by less affection, but other children require more love, more affection, more understanding. Maybe that's what Kashmiri's need. What they crave for. 

Mr Prime Minister, instead of pride in my eyes, I fear for my life when I see the Indian Army uniform. Is that what a citizen should feel like? Instead of being able to freely express myself, I can neither connect to the internet, speak on the phone, or even leave my house. Is that what a citizen should feel like? Instead of proudly waving my Indian passport on the streets, I'm hiding it inside closed wardrobes. Is that what a citizen should feel like? I'm quite a simple person, I don't have any high and unachievable demands. Neither am I asking you to grant us freedom from India, nor am I filing a complaint against our government and the rest of the world. I can understand what we are all warped up in is far too complicated for an outsider like me to understand. For what would I know, I'm just an ordinary 17 year old girl, coming to my hometown to visit my family, and now stuck on a desolate land with only mourning and melancholy in the air. And it seems like, just like every other soul in this beautiful, isolated valley, I'm begging for my voice to be heard.

(Fatima Shamim studies at Tbilisi Georgia)

Related Stories

No stories found.